From Publishers Weekly
A teacher for many years, Evans (The Door at the End of the Hall) presents a whimsical, absurdity-charged satire. Bradley is stuck with one nightmare of a teacher, Mrs. Gross ("The chinless face, the squinty eyes, and a thick lower lip pushed out in a permanent scowl reminded [Bradley] of an overripe apple"). If readers don't get the picture from the descriptions, Di Fiori's hyperbolic line drawings leave no doubt that Mrs. Gross is wickedly off-putting, right down to the hairs on her chinny chin chin. Bradley realizes her thinking is a bit askew when she instructs her students that there's no need to put "the dumb b at the end of climb" and shows them a map of the U.S. containing 70 states. The nine-year-old then learns that he and his classmates are victims of Operation Misteach, a plot hatched on Apple Island, where Mrs. Gross lives with the rest of the world's crabbiest teachers. On a field trip there, Bradley separates from the group and encounters amusingly eccentric individuals who reveal the history of this outlandish land where lunch boxes sprout from the ground, boulders are made of chalk and paper grows on trees alongside an ink lake. Evans's imagery and wordplay are occasionally strained or redundant, but he compensates with many wry tidbits. Ages 6-10.
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 4-6-Bradley Zimmerman knows that something is just not right at school. His teacher, Mrs. Gross, new to the school, seems to be teaching everything all wrong. His suspicions are confirmed when he overhears her talking in the faculty room about Operation Misteach and that all of the children will soon be deliberately taught inaccurate information. Bradley and his classmates then find themselves on their way to Apple Island, the source of this evil plot. There, the children are brainwashed in the Operation Misteach regimen so that these evil teachers can control what their students think and know. Bradley escapes and musters support from the principal, secretary, bus driver, and custodian, all of whom remember the good teachers that left, leaving the likes of Mrs. Gross, a.k.a. Mrs. Eraser. She would make any child shutter. Readers also meet the ineffectual principal and the librarian who is literally living in the library and reading her way through the collection. While the story is somewhat heavy-handed, it has its humorous and adventurous moments. Line drawings illustrate Bradley's journey to justice. An additional purchase.
Cheryl Cufari, Glencliff Elementary School, Niskayuna, NYCopyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.