3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Bill, February 24, 2010
This review is from: Application Service Provider and Software as a Service Agreements Line by Line: A Detailed Look at ASP and Saas Agreements and How to Change Them to Meet Your Needs (Paperback)
I was very much looking forward to this book as I'd purchased the book
Software Agreements Line by Line: A Detailed Look at Software Contracts and Licenses & How to Change Them to Fit Your Needs just before purchasing this one thinking that the ASP and SaaS book would be in the same style and would cover content in the same way, especially since both books are from the same publisher.
To be fair, because I purchased both at about the same time much of my comparison is based on what I found good or not so good in both books. I use these types of books as reference. Although I will generally read them cover to cover at least once, once I have, they become part of my collection of reference books.
In my opinion, the Software Agreements Line by Line is easier to read and follow then the ASP and SaaS Line by Line book. For example, there were "Example Revision" boxes throughout the Software Agreements Line by Line book that showed the suggested drafting changes in redline format so the reader would know exactly what the author's meant when changing language from the original to the modified language. Additionally there were checklists that highlighted the important issues at the end of each section.
In the ASP and SaaS book, it was more difficult (although not impossible) to follow what the authors were suggesting as alternatives. For a Line-by-Line book it seemed short on example language, and in some areas the reader was left to guess. One example, when discussing language related to license grant, the authors suggest that "A more customer-friendly license grant would expand the license to an enterprise-wide scope...". To assist the reader, it would have been helpful if the authors had followed-up with an actual drafted example to avoid the reader having to guess what that language might look like.
Another issue, although mostly an annoyance, was the Table of Contents, or rather the lack of one in the ASP and SaaS book. It was 4 lines with the first line being the "Introduction" and the last one "About the Authors".
The Table of Contents in the Software Agreements Line by Line filled up one and a half pages. If you use any book as a reference the lack of a reasonably detailed Table of Contents makes it tedious and much more difficult.
There will be much in common between two books that discuss software agreements since they are going to have to cover much of the same ground in regards to the terms and conditions. The ASP and SaaS book covered the general terms and conditions you'd expect to see in a software agreement. Since ASP and SaaS agreements are a newer type of software (or service) agreement, the ASP and SaaS book could have added a significant value by providing more detail what makes an ASP or SaaS contract different from the ordinary software agreement. It does this to some extent although most of that discussion is in the first 3 pages of the introduction with some brief references to this topic scattered throughout the book.
If you're an attorney or contract analyst/administrator with experience in drafting software agreements this book probably won't bring much new information related to ASP and SaaS issues and concerns that you couldn't get by researching the Internet. If you're looking to add to your library of books, plan on working with many ASP and SaaS agreements, and have a $100+ to burn then it might be worth it to have it on your shelf.
However, if you are someone without any experience in working with software agreements I'd suggest starting with the "Software Agreements Line by Line" book which is significantly less expense, easier to follow, has checklists, and makes a much better reference book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No