Customer Reviews

Appomattox (The Civil War Battle Series, Book 10)

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is the first James Reasoner book that I have ever listened to. The story is well done and a good depiction of the life of Southerners during the Civil War, particularly of women on the home front. As another reviewer said, I wish the author had finished off some of the story lines. For example, he does not take the Brannons to Texas. He does not tell what happens to the former slave, Roman, who is the central character in the first chapter of the book. As an animal lover, I would love to know what happens to the grey stallion.

However, in my estimation, Lloyd James, the narrator of the audio version made the book. I listen to a lot of audio books and James has now risen to the top of my list of narrators. His ability to change his voice and the wide variety of voices that he uses is amazing. But for James, I would certainly have lost interest in this book.

It's well worth the listen.

APPOMATTOX, the 10th and final volume in James Reasoner's THE CIVIL WAR BATTLE SERIES, certainly lives up to the preceding nine volumes. The ending of the Civil War, and the conclusion of the Brannon family saga during the conflict, is once again well-researched, and tautly written.

Mr. Reasoner gives us characters we can relate to and care about, from the Brannon family, to Cory Brannon's wife Lucille, to Pie Jones and his wife Rachel, to Roman, Will Brannon's now freed slave, to the fearless men of the Texas Rangers, and even many of the minor characters. The reader can't help but becoming deeply involved with the lives of the characters. And, as always, the battle scenes are fraught with tension.

I only wish the author had taken the book one step further, and had the Brannons reach their final destination, rather than still searching for their new future. However, this is a minor point, and certainly detracts little, if at all, from a riveting series.

APPOMATTOX, as are all the books in THE CIVIL WAR BATTLE SERIES, is must reading for any fan of excellent historical fiction, and also highly recommended for Civil War buffs.

Mac, Cory, and Titus are still in the desperate fighting of the southern army in the last days of the war. Reasoner did not close the story of the minor characters of the saga. The Brannons were left remarkably intact except for Will. The war was over and the characters were looking ahead to a new future. Reasoner could have a sequel or two to see how the after-affects of this cruel war were on his characters. A very good series. By Ruth Thompson author of "The Bluegrass Dream' and "Natchez Above The River"

The book was in excellent condition and delivery
was fast. I would not hesitate to order from
this source again.

I'm glad I had all 10 books before I started reading them. I couldn't put them down once I started. I would love for James Reasoner to pick up the story of the family in Texas. I'm a Civil War buff. Reasoner added enough fiction with non-fiction to make the books really interesting. Books usually don't affect me too much, but it broke my heart when Will died. James Reasoner is an excellent author and I hope to find more books by him. Thanks Mr. Reasoner for a wonderful adventure.

For the first several volumes in The Civil War Battle Series the great irony in James Reasoner's books was that the particular battle that served as the title was usually covered in a relatively few pages at the end of the book. More than the strategy and tactics of a particular battle, however, the narrative was more caught up with the interpersonal problems of the Bannon family of Culpeper County, Virginia, so that many of us thought the series should be called The Civil War Soap Opera Series. I knew how the war was going to turn out, my biggest concerns was Duncan Ebersole getting his comeuppance and with how many of the Brannons would still be alive at the end of the tenth and final book. The latter concern actually last longer because it was not until the end of the ninth volume, "Savannah," that Will Brannon became the first of the five Bannon brothers to get killed in the war.

One of the reasons that the Bannons lasted so long was that they were essential to the far flung nature of Reasoner's narrative. Originally this was just Will and Mac in the Eastern Theater of the war, with the Stonewall Brigade and the Confederate cavalry at Manassas, Antietam, Chacnelllorsville and such while Cory represented the Western Theater from Shiloh to Vicksburg. Even once Henry and Titus got involved in the war, leaving Coredlia home on the farm with ma, they were busy covering other aspects of the war. Now, all the chickens come home to roost in the final book. Of course, Appomattox is really not a Civil War battle per se, not compared to Gettysburg and Chicamauga, but the site of Lee's surrender of the Army of Northern Virginia to Grant. This means that Reasoner has to cover a lot once he begins "Appomattox" with Mac and Roman burying Will.

Mac is still with Fitzhugh Lee's Confederate cavalry while Titus is not a member of Mosby's Rangers engaged in guerrilla warfare in the Shenandoah Valley. By the end of the book Mac is involved with the defense of Petersburg and Titus is actually involved with a desperate plot to save the Confederacy that allow Reasoner to make him a part of American history. Meanwhile Cory is now part of the retreating Rebel army facing Sherman in the Carolinas and Henry is riding with Nathan Bedford Forrest in Alabama. Back at the farm Cordelia is still being courted by a Yankee lieutenant while Nathan Hatcher is serving with the Union army in the Dakota Territory and Cory's wife Lucille is heading to Texas to meet up with Pie and Rachel while waiting for the war to end so Cory can join her. Throw into the mix what happens to Roman and this novel moves at a faster pace than any of the rest. It often seems like Reasoner is bouncing around from character to character, making sure he is touching all his narrative bases. By the end of this book characters in different parts of the war are showing up in the same chapter, which was not what was happening before.

In winding down the war the soap opera elements are about as reduced as the health and fitness of the Confederate army. There was really only one significant element left and it unexpected just sort of ends, so Reasoner is able to keep the focus on the reactions of the Brannons to the drawing end of the war. Capturing the reactions of the surviving Brannon brothers to what is happening is the strongest part of this book, even if he is forced to rush through the final months of the drawn out war. Still, it is hard not to be struck by how odd at the quick pace of this final book at the end of a ten volume series. If you go by the number of reviews written about each volume in The Civil War Battle Series it would seem there have been some massive desertions along the way, but overall the series holds up well and even if a couple of the Bannons become officers (a helpful way of having them in the right place with the right people at the right time) you do get a sense of what it was like for the ordinary soldiers of the Civil War.