48 of 49 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Somewhat disappointing, June 8, 2005
This review is from: Aquarium Designs Inspired by Nature (Hardcover)
Given the glowing reviews I read on this site, I was somewhat disappointed with the book when it finally arrived. The general information is fine, as far as it goes, if on a rather basic level. I guess what annoyed me most was that the author makes only a half-hearted effort to use plants indigenous to the various biotopes he describes--for example, Anubias, an African genus, finds its way into the Amazon acid pool. Also, the lists of appropriate fishes are fairly sketchy. And maybe I'm alone in this, but I found it odd that none of the finished biotope aquaria are photographed with fish in them!
What I was hoping for was information on a par with that provided on the Italian website www.natureaquarium.it; this book, while pleasant enough, doesn't begin to reach that level of sophistication or specificity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
47 of 50 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Beginer's aquarium book only!, November 14, 2005
This review is from: Aquarium Designs Inspired by Nature (Hardcover)
Is java fern found in an Australian river, I don't think so. This book is not accurate!
All of the aquarium displays are not even mature, probably because most of the plants would be quite unhealthy by the time the display is mature enough to photograph, very unprofessional!
Another example: there are no mangroves in the mangrove swamp design, Hygrophila corymbosa was used instead with the author stating it is a good substitute for mangroves, what the, right up until the brackish water kills it! What's almost as worse is that the heater is not even hidden in the aquarium background.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
28 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Compared to a previous version....., March 1, 2005
This review is from: Aquarium Designs Inspired by Nature (Hardcover)
I'm going to start off by saying that this book is basically an updated version of "Creating a Natural Aquarium", by the same author. This being said I'm going to compare the two in this review.
"Aquarium Designs Inspired by Nature" (ADIBN) is a very good book for anyone who has wanted to turn their aquarium from a mix and match display to a strict biotope aquarium. Its divided in two parts, the first is a "practical section" that covers the water cycle, substrates and decoration, plants, water conditions and planning. ADIBN goes into some detail on the subjects but doesn't go as far as a textbook and make it boooooring. It is good information for aquarists of all levels. In the other book, "Creating a Natural Aquarium" (CANA), the same information is covered in Part 1, but to a lesser degree and CANA omits some small sections. Part 1 of both books is really very similar and I wouldn't choose one based on the small differences. The important factor, in my opinion, the differences in part 2.
Part 2 of ADIBN covers more biotopes than Part 2 of CANA, which I will list below. The biotopes that are in both books are virtually the same, with ADIBN giving a little more information about each. In the following list I will list the biotope sections and then which book it is in.
Mountain Stream (CANA) split up in ADIBN
*Chinese Mountain Stream (ADIBN)
Central American Stream (BOTH)
Central American River (BOTH)
Australian River (BOTH)
European River (BOTH)
*European Lake (ADIBN)
Flooded Forest (CANA) Same as Below
Flooded Amazon Forest (ADIBN)
Amazon Acid Pool (Both)
*Downriver Amazon (ADIBN)
*Congo Whitewater River (ADIBN)
*West African Streambed (ADIBN)
Lake Malawi (BOTH)
Darkened Cave (BOTH)
*Southeast Asian Stream (ADIBN)
Southeast Asian Swamp (BOTH)
*Indian River (ADIBN)
Brackish Estuary (BOTH)
Mangrove Swamp (BOTH)
Personally I prefer Aquarium Designs Inspired by Nature because it includes a few extra biotypes and goes into a little more depth about each biotype. Aquarium Designs... is also a larger book so there are more pictures and they are larger. Aquarium Designs... uses the pictures from Creating a Natural Aquarium and adds a few. I like pictures, so this personal preference.
CONCLUSION:
If you want a little more detail and a few extra biotopes then go with AQUARIUM DESIGNS INSPIRED BY NATURE. If cost is a factor CREATING A NATURAL AQUARIUM is usually cheaper, and if you don't really care about the extra details missing CANA is as good as ADIBN. Both books are helpful in pointing you in the right direction and no matter which you pick you will be happy. ( I Hope) These are the best books I have found (so far) that describe natural environments for the home aquarium.
GOOD LUCK!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No