'"Cet ouvrage remarquable et agriable lire sera disormais indispensable tout historien de cette rigion d'Afrique.'
J.-P. L, "Mideo.
'"The volume has been produced to the high standard to be expected of this publisher and is lavishly illustrated. It is useful to read, as offering a different perspective from these memoirs.'
C.F. Beckingham, "Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, 1994.
'..".van Donzel's richly annotated translation is the fullest to date, comprising not only the memoirs themselves, but Ruete's sequel to the memoirs and some important miscellania...The enlarged edition is useful to social historians of the Middle East, historians of colonialism, and, because it is conveniently excerptable, suitable reading for students, particularly in that still thinly covered era of Middle Eastern women's history, where primary, inside sources by women are so scarce.'
Billie Melman, "International Journal Middle Eastern Studies, 1995.
'"Ihr exemplarischer Wert besteht nich zuletzt in der sorgfdltigen Darstellung der angef]hrten Belege.'
Ludmila Hanisch, "Anthropos, 1994.
'..".un viritable trisor d'informations.'
Randi Deguilhem, "Bulletin d'Itudes Orientales.
'"Rarely is a reviewer so fortunate as to receive a book which is such sheer pleasure to read. Richly illustrated, beautifully produced...The book should be required reading for all those interested in the Middle East, in Muslims in the West, in ethnography, and in translational phenomena in general. E. van Donzel and E.J. Brill must be congratulated on producing this exciting and first-rate volume.'
Fedwa Malti-Douglas, "Journal of the American Oriental Society, 1996.
'"Ein in all seinen Teilensehr lesenswertes, historisch, vor allem dank van Donzels gr]ndlicher Recherchen, hvchst aufschlu_reiches Buch!'
Wiebke Walther, "Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenldndischen Gesellschaft, 1996.