Most Helpful Customer Reviews
27 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Tension of Human Ambition Unresolved, January 17, 2000
Humans have a natural distaste for experiences of tension. We tend to want to resolve the tension by giving into one of the forces. The topic of ambition, particularly in America, is one fascinating tension: we believe deeply in the power of the individual to rise above humble means and yet, we tend to resent those who have achieved great wealth, e.g. Bill Gates. Ambition has its seemy side and its positive side. Ambition implies that there is competition and in that competition, there will be some who come out on top. This is the tension of ambition in a capitalistic society and economy. As a result, any author who dealt with ambition would be tempted to slide toward either extreme: ambition is good or ambition is evil. Champy and Nohria successfully fail to resolve the tension for the reader. They lift up the amazing trait of ambition with biographical examples and describe the occasionally ambiguous trait with other essential traits without questioning the motives or ethics of ambitious people. Their thesis is that ambition is the driver for success in the world. Fortunately, they use a broad definition of success by profiling artists, businessmen, social activists, religious leaders, etc. They describe the three phases of the arc of ambition: the upward incline with its accompanying struggles, the peak of success and the inevitable decline that eventually occurs in each ambitious person's life. Their profiles help the reader understand each phase, the supporting experiences and traits and the opportunities and risks of each one. The authors have written a business book that is not written with common, stale prose. While it is not as exciting to read as a Tom Peters book, it is definitely far from a Peter Senge anesthetic. They also assume an intelligent reader who can draw his or her own conclusions about the nature of ambition. After reading this book, I have been very encouraged and excited about where I am currently at on my arc of ambition. I have a better understanding of what I am doing and how I am wired. This is a worthwhile read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
That distinguishing quality....that defining moment....., January 16, 2000
By A Customer
Generally,a healthy sceptic of management philosophies - especially when it comes to implementing them in real life -I found the book provocative and eye-opening. Champy and Nohria have managed to effectively pinpoint that "ineffable quality", possessed by leaders, across time and chosen paths. The creativity of ideation, the pioneering courage to follow it through and also, importantly, the ability to let go. Teaching, demonstrating and implementing leadership principles is at best an elusive, challenging process. The book coalesces similarities possessed by leaders(fleshed out by invorating examples from the political, business and social spheres), and lays them out in a crisp, easy to understand fashion. The title says it all. The reader after having read the book, is strongly tempted to pick it up and read it again. Some day more management books will be written this way.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Travelling the Arc, February 24, 2000
Nohria and Champy do an admirable job of examining the power and potential of ambition. Not easy ground as ours is a culture that is almost embarrassed by the word. Ambition is negative. Ambition consumes. Ambition is selfish. History shows otherwise and Nohria and Champy use historical case studies to dramatic effect. Yes, ambition has been at the core of some figures we could have done without. But, so too did it burn in many who made massive contributions to mankind. It was downright merciful of the authors not to bury us in the typical motivational pap that usually greets us when matters of business and character meet. Overall, a clever treatment of a tough subject that manages to both educate and entertain.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|