| ||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Archaeology and T The New he Ancient Maya,
By keely turnbull (canada) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The New Archaeology and the Ancient Maya ('scientific American' Library) (Paperback)
There are many books written on the subject of the Maya civilization. What sets Jeremy Sabloff's book apart from the rest is how he approaches the subject. He refers to his book as a story, and provides his reader with a very concise overview of the Maya civilization. The clarity of his text enhances the usefulness of the book, which in turn broadens the audience from anthropology students to anyone interested in learning about the Maya. Sabloff sets out his `story' to combine history, theory, methods and fieldwork and best describes the text in his own preface, an "attempt to explain how early archaeologists arrived at the `traditional model' of ancient Maya civilization that was popular in the first half of the century and how fieldwork has given birth to new discoveries of the Maya." (Sabloff, preface). The text is broken down into six chapters and in each chapter he uses subheadings to organize his interpretation of the information and to reveal an accurate knowledge of Maya studies. Using Maya archaeology as an extended study, Sabloff uses relevant sites during specific time periods as case studies to examine the area he wishes to describe to his reader. The first chapter is entitled `Growth of Modern Scientific Archaeology',almost beginning were the preface left on in terms of what Sabloff views as the `traditional model' of early Maya archaeology. This begins with the idea of what stream of questions the archaeologist should ask. In the `traditional model', Sabloff shows that the `what' and `where' questions of the past are no longer as relevant as the newly replaced `why' and `how' shift. It is in this chapter that Sabloff introduces the first of many different scholars to emphasize each section. Schiffer and Binford are discussed as well as one of their more popular methodological issues of the past, linked cultural activities. The next two chapters give the reader a contrast with the `traditional model' of ancient civilization and new views of the classic period. With these topics, Sabloff refers to the findings of Morley and Thompson in chapter two and Willey and Proskouriakoff in the following section. The way he introduces these scholars is one of respect. Sabloff does not bash the early ideas of archaeologists (knowing now that the information is not thorough), he describes their work prior to the archaeological revolution as successful and that many of their ideas were not wrong, just not developed enough. With regards to the later of the four scholars, Sabloff explains Proskouriakoff's remarkable findings from the Usumacinta River sites of Piedras and Yaxchilan and the breakthrough idea that Maya texts record history. What Sabloff seems to stress is that with each decade, the scholars and the information they have gathered help the next generation of archaeologists in their quest to better understand Maya civilization. Chapter four evaluates new views of the Pre-classic and Post-classic period. Sabloff introduces specific case studies such as the areas of Chichen Itza and Cozumel. By focusing in on these areas, Sabloff is able to convey to his reader an understanding of what archaeology can accomplish. The remaining two chapters analyze the emergence of a new model and takes a look at archaeology under this new modern world. Sabloff highlights the scholars Webster and Gonlin and their research on the emergence of more distant rural areas among the Maya subareas. With each chapter, Sabloff gives the reader a new finding in terms of Maya civilization. He frequently looks for parallels between ourselves and the Maya which make this civilization even more real and exciting to the reader. The `story' concludes with Sabloff asking questions to the reader, and having read the book, the questions encompass so much information in only a few lines. Sabloff leaves the reader thinking as well as feeling confident enough to ponder the questions himself. After the final word has been read, there are ten pages of further readings listed by chapter, which include everyone mentioned in the book and then some. `The New Archaeology and the Ancient Maya' is lavishly illustrated with photographs, site plans and maps all of which are in colour. All of these visual aids in conjunction with the accurate read, help to summerize this complicated subject with success. Sabloff hits his target perfectly with how he feels this story should be told, his story is "to understand the development of a past culture, not find lost arks".
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent overview of Mayan Archaeology,
By K. Maxwell "katmax1" (Sydney, Australia) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The New Archaeology and the Ancient Maya ('scientific American' Library) (Paperback)
I found this book very informative. It demonstrates how much archaeology and our knowledge of the Maya has changed since the Mayan ruins were first 'discovered' in the 19th century. The cultural biases of the early archaeoligts now explain many of the 'facts' put forward in early books on this subject. Acutally many of these 'facts' were just guesses, but because they were put forward by prominent people they were taken on face value. Much of the work, especially since the 1960's has disproved or changed out of recognition these early 'facts'. The last overview book on the Maya I read had them as peace loving people in lovely cities in the jungle, who just "gave it all up for no decent reason". This book completly changed my view on that. It made me realise on how slim a foundation many of the earlier works lay. I'd reccomend this book to anybody who wants to know how much archaeology has changed - and why what these people have discovered is not only in the past, but also has a bearing on us today..
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Credititis, and old,
By
This review is from: The New Archaeology and the Ancient Maya ('scientific American' Library) (Paperback)
This nicely illustrated book is very disappointing. Sabloff lards almost every paragraph with credit to named researchers: "Wackford Squeers of the Hann Barbera Museum of the University of Urkutsk ..." People deserve credit, but the place for it is endnotes or footnotes. And that is just one symptom of a tendency throughout to pad, and to write clumsily. Ahh you say, but what about the science? Well I found less of it than I expect from a Scientific American book, and it is now 20 years old as well.Not a dreadful book, just not a particularly good one, and out of date.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|