29 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Rutlemania Redux, March 10, 2000
With the release of the Beatles' Anthology series, it was inevitable that the surviving Rutles would follow suit and dig into their vaults to serve up a CD-ful of outtakes, alternate versions and previously unreleased songs that weren't considered strong enough for the original Rutles' albums like Ouch!, A Hard Day's Rut or Tragical History Tour.
Too bad it took the tragic death of Dirk McQuickly for the surviving Rutles to comb through the vaults to serve up this 16-track collection of bits and pieces of Rutlemania. While these songs were never intended for official release, it provides a rare glimpse into the the previously unreleased vaults of perhaps the most overrated band in the history of popular music. Tracks like "Joe Public" clearly show the undeniable effects of tea abuse among the Rutles. Drummer Barry Wom was usually limited to a single vocal per album, and it's a joy to hear him on "Rendezvous," a track that would have fit in nicely on Sgt Rutters. There's an extended combined edit of "Hey Mister!" but it's not the long-rumored three-hour version. "Shagri-La" could have been as big a hit as "Good Times Roll" or "Doubleback Alley." Confessional songs like "Don't Know Why" point the direction Ron Nasty's career would take after the break-up of the Rutles. With talk of a Rutles' reunion now a moot point, the lyrics to "Back in '64" resonate with new meaning: "Life is too short to be small...so, so long...it's all over." RECOMMENDED
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Patience will be Rewarded, February 21, 2003
At first, this album appears a pale imitation of The Rutles soundtrack album. But after listening a couple of times, I fell in love with Archeology, too. The wit is not sledgehammer, but it is there. Many of the songs were written by Neil Innes years ago and have now been given "the full Rutles treatment."
There is plenty of parody here, especially of The Beatles' Anthology project. This collection contains some of Innes' most insightful lyrics. As Homer Simpson says, It's funny because it's true.
Here are some of my favourites:
Major Happy's Up and Coming Once Upon A Good Time Band [Guess which song it parodies!], appropriately followed by a very amusing poke at With a Little Help From My Friends called Rendezvous
Questionnaire sounds like Fool On the Hill meets Imagine AND I Am the Walrus!
Lonely-Phobia sounds like it comes from the Help era, with acoustic guitars and serious lyrics that betray its earlier origin
The Knicker-Elastic King is another Penny Lane parody, in the style of Doubleback Alley
Here is a snippet:
Knicker Elastic - essence of propriety
Knicker Elastic - upholder of society
The price of raw materials
coupled with inflation
squeezed his global holdings
his liquid assets bottomed out
and shrunk his retail outlet operation
Eine Kleine Middle Klasse Musik is in the style of Not Guilty and has bitingly satrical lyrics, which Innes admits, mock his own lifestyle as much as anybody else's.
Another lyric extract:
Look at all the nice things money can buy
Every day there's more and more
Do you ever stop and wonder why
you need to lock your door?
Loneliness is all that
people ever share
Smuggling their pain through
'Nothing To Declare'
Living next to people
who agree to disagree
Happy in a pie-chart
society
Shangri-La is a fun song, which sounds like it could have come from Abbey Road, but with a For No One horn solo, and a long, singalong, Hey Jude-type ending.
Great fun. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thanks for all the fish, December 6, 2002
By A Customer
Quite apart from the fact that Neil Innes, John Halsey and Ricky Fataar get it spot-on every time with these send-ups of The Beatles, it's also evident that they loved both the original source material and its' creators. The main reference points seem to be late-period rather than early-period Fab Four, but the Prefab (Three) Four also visit that earlier time now and again, and all of it's done up well. What's especially nice is that many of these songs hold up on their own even after you've "gotten" the joke. "I Love You" won't make anyone forget "And I Love Her" or "If I Fell," but it's actually a sweet little song in it's own write (thanks, John!) and I at least find myself humming it as much as anything the Beatles actually wrote.
The most disquieting song, however, is "Don't Know Why," where it's almost as if John Lennon has been channeled from the void for one last comment about Beatlemania and what it all meant. Innes and Company make no bones about it; "it" (Beatlemania, the Sixties, etc.) was fun while it lasted and it's all over now. Certainly a sentiment Lennon would have approved of, but it won't blunt your enjoyment of this great collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No