This book should be read by a readership wider than that composed of specialists in the Bronze Age eastern Mediterranean, as the world-systems approach remains a powerful tool and should not be dismissed as so last century. --Antiquity, vol. 84, issue 326, December 2010
This book should be read by a readership wider than that composed of specialists in the Bronze Age eastern Mediterranean, as the world-systems approach remains a powerful tool and should not be dismissed as so last century. --Antiquity, vol. 84, issue 326, December 2010
...The chapters in this volume each work toward a common goal of using a greater range of theoretical approaches in order to address social interaction the Aegean world and its relationship with the wider eastern Mediterranean.... The chapters are almost necessarily contradictory.... The willingness of the editors to allow for contradictory views is a positive step toward enriching the field of Aegean prehistory. A reasoned and explicit statement about the approaches taken is always a valuable part of any study ...it is clear that the editors and authors have thought carefully about their approaches to the evidence and its evaluation. It is hoped that such clearly stated eclecticism will continue to form part of the study of state societies in the eastern Mediterranean Bronze Age. --Joanna S. Smith, Bryn Mawr Classical Review, 5/2011
Parkinson and Galaty are to be commended for both the idea of this...volume and for its execution. The editors have worked hard to ensure a diversity of approaches and to contextualize these in ways useful to both anthropologists and ancient historians. The result is a substantive, largely jargon-free lesson in how theoretical models may be applied to data not usually viewed in this way. It will be a good teaching tool and a good bridge among disciplines. --Cynthia W. Shelmerdine, University of Texas, Austin
Archaic State Interaction casts valuable new light on how extra-societal contacts may be implicated in processes of increasing social complexity. As the title makes clear, the contributors ground their discussions of interaction theory in the specific sequence of events dating to 3100-1000 BCE in that portion of the Mediterranean basin stretching from Italy to the Levantine Coast. Their goals, as stated clearly by Parkinson and Galaty in the introduction, are to consider how local social and economic changes, on the one hand, were related to: variations in the intensity of interactions occurring at differing spatial and temporal scales; changes in how, and by whom, such contacts were conducted; and, shifts in the routes these transactions followed. The result is less a consensus than a healthy, productive debate on these issues. --Edward Schortman, Journal of World-Systems Research, vol. xvii, no. 2, 2011
Parkinson and Galaty are to be commended for both the idea of this...volume and for its execution. The editors have worked hard to ensure a diversity of approaches and to contextualize these in ways useful to both anthropologists and ancient historians. The result is a substantive, largely jargon-free lesson in how theoretical models may be applied to data not usually viewed in this way. It will be a good teaching tool and a good bridge among disciplines. --Cynthia W. Shelmerdine, American Journal of Archaeology Book Review, July 2011