3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Read more like propaganda than a romance novel, February 16, 2006
This review is from: Arizona Ecstasy (Paperback)
From the back cover:
Arizona Bride...
Lovely Lisa Powers hated the Indian who captured her. He had killed her mother, ransacked her wagon and now planned to plunder her virtue. But as days in the arid Southwest became weeks and months, the fair-skinned Illinois beauty turned to the Apache brave first for survival, then for love. And with only the sky and the desert to witness, Lisa declared that in her heart he was her husband and for all time she would be his wife.
Arizona Heartbreak...
Because he was a half-breed, the warrior Chaco knew the misery that could result from loving a white woman. He told himself that she was evil, that her kind killed Indians, that her life would be awful as a nomadic Apache squaw. Still, his strong hands couldn't help but fondle her; his sensual lips had to fully taste her. And even though he sensed he'd one day send her back to her people, Chaco couldn't resist stealing each breathless moment of their Arizona Ecstasy.
The sequel to Arizona Bride.
And my review:
While this was a sequel book, I hadn't read "Arizona Bride", but I wasn't lost at all. I think this book worked just fine as a stand-alone.
I normally love the works of Rosanne Bittner. While I haven't found many keepers amoung them, I've always found them entertaining for a one-time read.
But lately, I've been getting very dissapointed in her. I was unable to finish this book, as well as another of hers, "Love's Bounty". Since this book was written in 1989, maybe it's just a case of it feeling 'dated'. I don't know.
My problem with this book was that the romance part of it didn't even begin until over a quarter of the way through. I shouldn't have to read over 100 pages before the heroine even appears. (Well, she appears in the very beginning, but for about 2 pages, then disappears for the next 100 pages.) If I'd wanted to read a book that was focused on the struggles of a half-Apache, half-white boy growing up in a white world that despises him, I wouldn't have picked up a romance. I want ROMANCE in my romance novel, and this just wasn't giving it to me.
My biggest complaint was the author's posturing on the issue of what was done to the Indians. Now, I'm not in any way a bigot (it'd be kind of hard for me to be, considering that I'm only half-white and in an interacial marriage!), but I found the author's continuous repetition of how great the Indians were and how awful the whites were to them to be tedious and annoying.
I do agree that what the majority of whites (and their government) did to Indians was appalling and very wrong; however, I don't want the view shoved down my throat. I wanted to read a piece of romantic fiction, not something that should be titled "Why Indians Were So Great, and How White People Were So Evil". I kind of felt like the author should have made her point, and then moved on, instead of repeatedly harping on it.
Also, the hero seemed to be quite one-dimensional in his hatred of white people. Yes, it was understandable, given how he was treated. However, he was portrayed as being completely justified in his prejudice towards whites, while the white prejudice towards Indians was portrayed as disordered and horribly wrong. Ummm, isn't that a bit of a double standard? All prejudice and racism is wrong, not wrong for just one side. The hero hates all white people for being racist against him - well, isn't that view in itself racist? Not all white people thought that way, even in those days.
I was unable to finish this, as this one-sided presentation of the issue got to be too irritating for me to go on. I will try some of Rosanne Bittner's other books, but she is fast dropping off my list of auto-buy authors.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No