Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The missing part..., August 19, 2000
"Around the world with Orson Welles", is great material for film buffs! Welles is directing himself, with usual flamboyance and visual flair. It does, though, seem somewhat overprized, especially considering that one of the six shorts is lacking! The back cover claims that "the last episode (Third Man Returns to Vienna) has been lost". This is not true. I taped it from the German television station ZDF some years ago, in excellent condition (better sound/picture quality than the materials on the DVD, sadly.) There it had the title: "Viva Italia". Apart from the misinformation and incompleteness of the release, it's especially sad for Welles fans because the Vienna episode is probably the best and most interesting of his semi-documentaries! Returning to the Harry Lime persona is just one of the highlights.. I still recommend the DVD though; thes travelogues are great fun!
|
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Viva Italia, August 23, 2000
A small retraction: the Orson Welles documentary "Viva Italia" is NOT "Third Man Returns to Vienna", but another great episode! It centers on Italy by telling the story of Gina Lollobrigida, also presenting a.o. Vittorio De Sica, whose great actor/director skills is implicitly used as a Welles parallel. It's a dynamic and truly wonderful episode, and should have been on the disc. The Image disc is still overprized, with it's sadly sloppy transfer and sparse presentation.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Semi-Engaging Bluff, March 11, 2007
Okay, "the French" think this is the "missing link" of Welles filmography. Now just think about that . . . who are these "French," and who supposedly speaks for them? The flummery evaporates upon even semi-serious attention, making one wonder whether master film maker (and open con artist) Orson was behind the crack, as the sort of exercise in self-promotion of which he was so capable.
Actually, Welles the man is very unusually engaging in these old TV shorts. The first two are the best, and after that you can slowly watch his engagement dwindle. That's the way it is with geniuses, they need to be challenged. Orson was always fascinated by TV, wrestling with it for years until his memorable "F for Fake" got fully engaged with both the stylistic and substantive new dimensions of fakery permitted and encouraged by the medium. These old Brit TV travel pieces were an opening shot, sure. But they are no more the "missing link" than was Piltdown Man (a cosmic con that Orson may well have regetted missing), or, for that matter, poor dying Citizen Kane's "Rosebud."
In episode one Orson introduces us to an old, eccentric American artist in Paris. Its a lovely, kind portrait, and one gets a feel of real time travel with roots back in the Paris heydey, for Americans, of the 1920s. There are also a couple classic Wellesian vistas of Paris, of such a touching beauty that only Orson could have shot them. They are too brief.
Then a piece on wonderful old Brit pensioners, some widows and soldiers he really hits it off with. The human dimension here, and the seriousness of Orson listening to these old folk make this quite special, and a fine short documentary in itself.
Now you expect the bullfight piece to be the best. Its not terribly bad, just dull, Orson letting the critic Kenneth Tynan and his wife do the talking. Orson should have skipped this shot at a mano a mano with Papa Hemingway on this turf. The actual bullfight footage is short, distant, altogether stock stuff -- Snooze in the Afternoon.
Some decent opening commentary comes in, and a few nice parting shots, in the two Basque pieces, really one piece edited in two different takes. Again, he basically lets friends speak. Its semi-engaging the first time, much less the second, then that's all, folks.
The worst aspect of these shorts is Orson's hammy, almost unpardonable trick of having a shot of him asking questions, then a shot of whoever the interviewee is answering them, and only rarely the two together -- obvious fakery of the most transparent variety. I wouldn't be surprized if this con was intentional. Ultimately, its not unpardonable because the masterpiece F for Fake eventually evolved out of such trickery.
Welles was an elusive cat, for all the time he spent on camera. The plus for Orson buffs (or for anyone) here is his genuine humor and compassion, never talking down to people. That obviously isn't trickery.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|