46 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Nostalgia, recipes, and history -- all well done, July 30, 2005
New York City Food is clearly aimed at those who grew up in New York, and I must include myself among them. Schwartz brings back the memories of the food we (and our parents) grew up with, and provides plenty of history that we never knew.
In 21 chapters, Arthur Schwartz covers NYC's food history. For example, a whole chapter is devoted to Delmonico's, which brought us such well-known dishes as the Delmonico steak, Delmonico potatoes, eggs benedict,and lobster newburg; the restaurant introduced the upper crust to such newfangled ingredients as eggplant and artichokes. The restaurant was important as a see-and-be-seen destination, but its less obvious influences are longer-lasting: it was the first successful a la carte restaurant in the U.S.
Five chapters are devoted to the food and influences of the major (and many) immigrants who came to New York City: the Germans (from delicatessens to Luchows), the Jews (the interview with Sol Kaplan, the original owner of Guss' Pickles, may make the book worth the purchase price), Italians, Irish, Chinese -- you get the idea. Other chapters focus on something historical or quintessentially New York: hot dogs, the glamour years (including the 21 Club), the golden age of cocktails.
Schwartz gives plenty of fun history -- at least it's fun if you have your own memories of Dinty Moore's, or remember your Mom wishing she could go to the Rainbow Room -- as well as a wonderful business and social context (such as the low regard with which the Irish were held in the 1800s, or why Diamond Jim was such a major figure in the City).
Even better, he provides recipes for many of the dishes that make New Yorkers most nostalgic. Everything from the original Thousand Island Dressing (introduced at the Waldorf) to a good knish. I haven't tried any of these, but they do make me swoon. (NYC has a reputation for pizza and bagels; the truth is you can get good versions of these in most major cities. Pickles and knishes, though -- that's another matter.)
All in all, it's entertaining and interesting -- and a lovely way to bring yourself back to childhood. It'll be a likely present for one of my sisters, who lives in California now; it's probably a good present for any of your ex-NYer friends, too.
Would it be as useful for a non-New Yorker? Not quite as much so. My husband grew up on a midwestern farm. Although he lived in NY for a couple of years, and he likes _New York City Food_, this book isn't quite as compelling for him.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
30 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This book is phenomenal!, November 19, 2004
It is the perfect gift for any New Yorker, former New Yorker, or wannabe NYer. I bought one for myself, showed it to my dad, and now I have to order another one for myself. I just love it - the photos and text are wonderful, and the recipes are an added treat. Arthur put so much work into this book, and I can honestly say it is a masterpiece! I am planning on bringing a copy to one of his appearances to get autographed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
great recipes, July 31, 2006
The history parts are interesting, and doubtless many people will buy the book for those alone. Just wanted to say that the recipes are excellent too - I've made the Blackout Cake, the Red Velvet Cake, and the Crumb Cake so far. All had excellent flavor and texture, and I'm looking forward to trying other recipes from this book, esp. the Lindy's cheesecake and Junior's cheesecake.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No