Most Helpful Customer Reviews
34 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Captivating story, September 13, 2007
This is a remarkable story of two women who meet under ordinary but perhaps unexpected circumstances. Astrid is practically a recluse who has lived almost her entire life under one roof. Veronika has traveled the world but at the time of their meeting she has retreated from her previous life and rented a secluded home in the countryside of Sweden that is within the view from Astrid's window. The two women have not led similar lives, they are not from similar backgrounds nor are they close in age. Each of them has separate reasons for distancing themselves from people and the world surrounding them. The contact between them begins reluctantly and continues very tentatively. With a very delicate touch and a precise focus, Olsson gradually removes veils of grief and allows the reader to watch a friendship grow between Astrid and Veronika as they share a brief time in the present and gradually share their pasts with each other. This is a very small story, set in a very small time and space, but it is totally captivating. While it is possible to read this novel as a story of one friendship, it also is a story of the power of human interaction to transform lives. Astrid and Veronika spend a relatively short time together, but as they find common ground they rediscover their essential humanity that enables each of them to better connect with their pasts and the world around them. Whether you view the essential common denominator as pain, as endurance or as love may be related to your personal view of the world. The novel is well written with an excellent sense of both characters and setting.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
49 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Some good things.., May 8, 2007
Astrid and Veronika meet as neighbors in a small Swedish village. Astrid is a hermit (the "town witch") and Veronika is a writer attempting to finish a novel. As their friendship deepens, the women find that they are each others' inspirations. Both are recovering from tragedies that have touched their lives, and the guilt that accompanies them. Much of the novel involves flashbacks as one character tells the other her secrets.
The book has its charms -- the prose is often lyrical, it moves quickly, and there is some nice location detail in Sweden, Japan, and New Zealand. Unfortunately, though, the plot is fairly obvious and the characterization is flat. At one point Astrid says to Veronika: "You pulled me out into the bright light again, opened my eyes. Made the ice thaw." The author doesn't do enough to plumb the relationship between these two. Most of these declarations don't feel earned. Astrid's character is similarly hard to understand. There is a lot of feminist subtext to her life, but a lot of it doesn't make complete sense.
In addition, the language veers into odd cliches. At one point, Astrid says: "My grandfather looked at me and it was as if we were the only two people in the whole world." Moments like that (there are several) drag the otherwise smooth narrative into soap opera territory.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
There is both a sparseness and sweetness to this story..., May 27, 2009
I won't recap the story, as others have done that nicely. I will say that this book explores the relationship between two women, one who has always lived in one place, the other a world traveler, who come from different generations and different perspectives to share their respective losses and their respective guilt. In sharing, they are set free. What touched me so was the way the story was told. I did not find the movement from one time and place to another at all jarring. It seemed fairly seamless to me. What I enjoyed the most was the descriptions of places that were at once spare and lush, leaving enough to my imagination. The author writes with great discipline and an appreciation for detail.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|