15 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not what I anticipated, February 3, 2009
This review is from: Atget: Photographe de Paris (Book on Books) (Hardcover)
When I first heard about this series of books, I thought it was a great idea. I collect photography books, but this particular book is out of my price range. I have many Atget books and thought it would great to have a reprint of his first book. Atget is one of my favorites, and the photos in this volume are some of his classics.
My problem with this book is how the publisher has elected to reproduce the original. The publisher's own description of the book in the pre-publication advertising states "Each volume in the series presents the entire content, page for page, of an original master bookwork .." What the don't say is that the majority of this reprint has four pages reproduced on each page, and two of those pages are blank. If you can imagine photocopying a book that has a photo on one page and a blank page opposite, then reducing that to fit two of these two-page spreads on a single page in this book, you will have an idea of what they've done.
This new reprint is a small volume to begin, measuring only 7 inches wide by 9 1/2 inches tall. A full page reproduction of an original page measures 6 1/2 x 8, but that includes the border, so the actual full-page image is only 5 x 6 1/2 inches. And remember, the facing page is blank. If the entire volume was done this way, I would be perfectly pleased, but there are only 19 full-page reproductions.
The rest of the book consists of 76 very small (2 3/8 x 3 inch) reproductions, all but three printed two per page, complete with the same size reproduction of the original page's blank facing page. The photos are still great, but my old eyes would have been much happier if the reproductions were all full page.
Technically, the publisher's statement I quoted at the start is true, but I did not expect "the entire content, page for page" to be reduced and printed four original pages on one of the new volume. As the publisher goes on to say, this series ".. allows further study into the creation and meanings of these great works of art." This would be true had the reproductions been full-page.
Someone familiar with the work of Atget may very well know many of the photos in this volume, and have larger reproductions in other books, and therefore may enjoy this book as an historical record of a long out-of-print edition (and I appreciate that aspect myself), but I wouldn't recommend this book for someone new to Atget , or one looking for larger prints to study.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
a treat, February 5, 2009
This review is from: Atget: Photographe de Paris (Book on Books) (Hardcover)
The Errata Edition's volume on the great photography book Phtographe De Paris is a book that I strongly recommend to lovers of photography. It is not a large, expensive volume which simply reproduces the original, and I suspect was not intended at all to be this, but it is an affordable reference work which I think others will get as much pleasure from as I do. The first part of the book reproduces the book of photographs, in a small size but very clearly, and this is followed by an original essay, which is full of information about Atget, the book itself, photography, these photographs, their content and their place in photography. This is a book that you can enjoy and learn from, at a price that will not set you book. It is a book that you will want to keep and return to. I am grateful that people who obviously love photography have made a lot of effort to share this with us. This and the other three books presently in the series are keepers in my opinion
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
books on books are good and good for you, February 5, 2009
This review is from: Atget: Photographe de Paris (Book on Books) (Hardcover)
The errata books on books series, as I understand it, are re-productions of important, out-of-print, rare - and therefore expensive - photobooks. I've spent some time with the first four, and they are done with intelligence, care, and seemingly with love for the work. Of course there's no substitute for the original editions, but that's sort of the point. The idea is to take each first edition seriously as a work of art, treat it with deference, make the work available to a wider audience, and add something to the mix in the form of a new essay and background information. Taking this first batch as indicative, there will be no fluff in this series -- the first four choices are powerful and interesting, both individually and in combination. Don't misunderstand: if you're considering selling your car and using the money to buy first editions of In Flagrante, Fait, etc. and a bicycle, well, that just might be a wise move and I admire you. Probably I should do exactly that. Until then, we're fortunate to have these books, and I look forward to more.
For what it's worth, you don't have to take my word: Parr & Badger each mentioned errata books on their `best of 2008' lists.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No