Most Helpful Customer Reviews
30 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
The Publisher should have known better!, January 6, 2004
This review is from: Athenais: The Life of Louis XIV's Mistress, the Real Queen of France (Hardcover)
I have been studying the Bourbon dynasty for many years, and am very familiar with the subject. Having just re-read Frances Mossiker's fabulous "Affair of the Poisons", I was intrigued when I spotted "Athenais" at a local bookstore. Over the course of 40 minutes I didn't read the whole thing, but certainly glanced over most of it, especially the sections dealing with the Poisons incident. I was shocked to see that she had lifted whole passages from Mossiker, with the barest attemp at re-phrasing! I found Mossiker in the bibliography, but nowhere was she footnoted in the entire chapter! Disgusted, I looked at the "Author"'s credentials too see who this lazy person was - a writer for VOGUE! What the F***? The publisher couldn't even get the lingerie on the cover right! Why was the cover model in a VICTORIAN nightie? I sincerely hope this book is not representative of the state of scholarship on this subject. I give it one star for having given employment to the guys at the presses.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Athenais c'est mauvais, February 24, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Athenais: The Life of Louis XIV's Mistress, the Real Queen of France (Hardcover)
I found this book to be spectacularly unfulfilling. It had neither the depth to be considered as a scholarly work nor the level of characterization for a fictionalized history. The main character remains, throughout the work unknown and undeveloped. Most of the information presented appears to be a fairly standard summation of previous works which is not assisted by the author's tendency to jump erratically from period to period with little regard for continuity. In summary, not a book which could be recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Athenais's true love is NOT Louis XIV, it's Lisa Hilton!!!, May 14, 2005
This review is from: Athenais: The Life of Louis XIV's Mistress, the Real Queen of France (Hardcover)
I've been fascinated with the decades of the Sun King's reign and the impact of his egomania on his country since I was 7 years old. Obviously, his women were a significant part of his life.
There are several things in Hilton's book that disturb me, not the least of which is her persistent effort to justify Athenais's worst personality traits as well as to either villify or ridicule her rivals. I mean, honestly, it's pushing it to depict Athenais as being "right" in abusing her friendships with the Queen and Louise de La Valliere (Louis's first mistress, who Athenais replaced) in order to "get closer" to the King and secure his "favor," only to turn around and depict Madame de Maintenon (who supplanted Athenais) as some sort of horned monstrous ingrate for "taking advantage of her benefactress to steal her love."
The reality of that era is that virtually the only person who had any real control over who he favored and slept with was Louis himself.
The speculation/conjecture about the Affairs of the Poisons, while perhaps not entirely unreasonable, still clings to the idea that Athenais was some sort of heroine ill-used and abused by the system of the times.
The book is not a total loss, but its extreme bias leaves me wondering if the author has first-hand experience of being the "other woman who got cheated on." Athenais is an intriguing figure in history, there was no need to canonize her less than admirable behavior at times. I would have had more respect for the work if there had been a little more objectivity to that point.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|