16 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Space Discovery, March 19, 2008
This review is from: An Atlas of Radical Cartography (Paperback)
Space Discovery:
A review of An Atlas of Radical Cartography
Review by Daniel Tucker
The fist time I went to Central New York state, was the first time I knew where it was. The first time I heard about Sudan on the news, was the first time I knew where it was and what was on the nearby borders. Our personal maps of the world are continuously changing. Through our experiences we become aware of places and ideas previously unfamiliar. Through culture and tourism we feel invited to explore what feels new to us. Through disasters and devastation we become conscious of locales that are further away that anywhere we could have imagined. All of this information and these experiences informs the expansion and creation of our map of the world and how it works.
Lize Mogel and Alexis Bhagat have edited "An Atlas of Radical Cartography" a beautifully designed 160 page book of ten essays, ten 17" x 22" maps, that all fold up and fit into an elegant slipcase. It's the second book to be released on the Journal of Aesthetics and Protest Press, a sister project to the original and ongoing annual Journal, which has become an important hub for critical and creative writing about the intersections of contemporary art and politics. The An Atlas collection is unique and unprecedented, collecting together many of the primary voices that have connected the visual and semiotic language of cartography with current political and artistic discourses.
The map is an obvious and practical device for people attempting to better understand the world in all its complexity, this project illuminates this "why mapping" question. Some of the reasons that essayist and map makers in this volume identify for their interest in maps include: shaping arguments, shaping policy, considering the continuity between geography without physical connections, as an ongoing research process, just to follow the connections between things we do every day and complex infrastructures, or to encourage a critical civic engagement and understanding of how things are planned and how they work.
An Atlas of Radical Cartography is an amalgamation of several different ideas. It is an experimental primer course in geography, a sampling of spatially oriented trends in contemporary art, a portable mini exhibit and a field guide to ongoing international debates about space and place. The collection of maps/essays starts to differentiate between the aesthetic experimentation and art trends that sample or reference geography, and the political mapping practices that take seriously their goals to change how we think about and use the world around us. An Atlas will be of interest to quasi-planners, drifting artists, experimental geographers, lovers of places, haters of maps, lost students and engaged citizens alike. It calls out attention to vital "radical cartography" work that is happening in cities and communities with which we could all relate. An Atlas asks us to handle maps, examine thoughts and rediscover space at a time when there is great confusion about what is where, what is near, how far is far, where we should go? An Atlas asks us to take great care with the world we currently have, to better understand its complexity and how it works, and to more thoughtfully consider how we are getting where we are going?
For more information
The project http://www.an-atlas.com/
The publisher http://www.joaap.org/
Bio: Daniel Tucker is the editor of AREA Chicago (areachicago.org). For more information see miscprojects.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
25 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing Results, April 6, 2008
This review is from: An Atlas of Radical Cartography (Paperback)
I heard the editors of this book on the radio and I was intrigued by the map ideas, but I was disappointed in the execution. Some of the maps are not maps, but drawings, such as the one of North and South America drawn in a faded red with the label across the continents "Latino/a America." Is this radical? Another, titled "Routes of Least Surveillance," shows surveillance cameras in Manhattan--but the data is from 2001, and there's no explanation of how the data was obtained. Perhaps the included book gives an explanation, but the map should stand on his own. It also has silly little vignettes of people--invented or real?--who might want to avoid the cameras, e.g., Wanda gets the creeps from the though of unsupervised male camera operators ogling her as she returns home from her Power Pilates class. Finally, I didn't find any of these maps particularly attractive or innovative--there's nothing I would want to put on my wall. You'll find much better designed maps in any of Tufte's books. If the point was to get me thinking about radical ideas through cartography, this book failed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Radical, April 3, 2009
This review is from: An Atlas of Radical Cartography (Paperback)
Tile explains everything - but if you need more information visit[...] Very up-to-date, to-the-point material. If you are looking for more "arty farty" stuff you will not be satisfied, if you are looking for genuine art - topology -sociology - territory creative thinking and critical observations, works that are covered in 10 maps and 10 essays are right for you.
Texts are clear, with useful informations and clear outcomes. Maps are clear, diverse and one might say beautiful.
A problem with packaging : maps when folded they all look the same. This makes it harde to look for map that goes together with certain section of the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No