24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
READ THE BOOK - Critique the content - not the author, August 20, 2005
This review is from: Atomic Iran: How the Terrorist Regime Bought the Bomb and American Politicians (Hardcover)
You may disagree with the politics - that is fair. However, when you read reviews that are based on the "person," only, rather then the content of the book- that is, in one word, sophomoric. For example, one reviewer stated: "More lies and distorions from the scum behind the Swift Boat liars. Don't waste your money." This offers what to any serious discussion. Further, I would garner a bet that the person has not read the book. Mr. Corsi posits some very serious theories, that if have an iota of truth, we should consider. If one person does not consider Iran to be an imminent threat to our society and way of life, that person lives in a land that contains the likes of the Easter Bunny and Santa Claus. This is a new world; what transpired on 9/11/01 change the world forever. Evaluate the content of the book; look for discrepancies or something to challenge his conclusions. Leave the personal attacks out. It accomplishes little.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
What if most of this is true?, February 14, 2006
This review is from: Atomic Iran: How the Terrorist Regime Bought the Bomb and American Politicians (Hardcover)
Anyone reading this who reasonably pays attention to daily world events should be able to see for themselves how close we are coming to an outright nuclear exchange. The section that describes in chilling detail what to expect if a moderate sized nuclear bomb detonates in New York is chilling to say the least!!
I know its ridiculous, but every member of congress and each of the nightly news anchors, should be forced to read this chapter. There is a very real danger here that dosen't seem to receive the attention it deserves, and our families and children will likely pay the price if something dosen't change. Maybe then we could get this nation to FOCUS on the catastrophic danger that faces the world provided madmen like these get a nuclear weapon. No one should expect Israel to stand idly by and let itself be obliterated, they will defend themselves and bring the United States along with them.
But rather than devote major attention to the very real threat percolating in Iran, the major media is more worried about why it took 24 hrs to inform them about the Vice President's hunting mishap, or the latest celebrity breakup in Hollywood!!
As a career Naval submarine officer, I worked up close and personal with nuclear missiles of several types. The idea of madmen like the president of Iran being willing to unleash that type of weapon against any country is bone chilling and breathtaking. This book will grab you by the lapel's and force you to consider the implications worldwide if an "Atomic Iran" comes to be.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
56 of 78 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Who's Next?, June 9, 2005
This review is from: Atomic Iran: How the Terrorist Regime Bought the Bomb and American Politicians (Hardcover)
[I am a retired Army Intelligence Officer - working now as a contractor for the Army as a computer combat simulations and modeling manager.]
I'll try my best to be objective - but, you know it's hard not to show your political stripes when reviewing this book. But why shoot us messengers? The fact that Dr. Corsi wrote a previous book that spiked John Kerry's Presidential bid - in no way nullifies the fact that Iran has - today - 3 to 5 nukes - and only hasn't used them because of the difficulty of mating them to their internally produced IRBMs.
Name callers - finger pointers - discussion groups - can wail all day long - (conspiracy freaks even longer) - but IRAN HAS THE BOMB!!! "Atomic Iran" gives a shorthand version of how their nuclear program successfully progressed - who remains complicit in it's development (Putin & Co, the Russians and an unsavory cast of Europeans, American businessmen and bureaucrats) and speculates on who are Iran's intended targets (easy speculation). The book may very well indeed foster sympathy to Israel, go soft on big oil and the Bush family - but this is trivial because we are still faced with people who intend to murder us all because we do not submit to Allah as interpreted by the Iranian mullahs!
Dr. Corsi plows through a religious, political, economic and emotional minefield - deliberately failing to avoid any of the mines. Apparently we either like explosions - or hate those who do. Graphic detail of hypothetical nuclear detonation incidents in Tel Aviv and NYC - might - just might - get some of us out from our TV sets and recreational diversions to reality.
In 1981, Israeli Air Force (IAF) F-16's dropped 24 bombs on the nuclear reactor containment structure at Osirak, Iraq. 22 of the 24 bombs landed within the concrete reactor building - effectively destroying Saddam Hussein's bid for nuclear domination of the Middle East.
Shortly after, Ronald Reagan stopped delivery of the next 75 F-16's Israel had on order (include Israel using US made cluster bombs on Palestinians in Lebanon for stopping this order) as the world (especially France who financed Iraq's nuclear program and lost a technician in the bombing) screamed in indignation. How fortunate we were that Israel was successful. Osirak was also dubbed "O'Chirac" after the then French foreign minister who headed France's participation in the project.
Fast forward to today. Iran has learned to hide and disperse it's nuclear production facilities. A strike "out of the blue" such as Osirak could not be completely successful without a massive intelligence effort and guaranteed success of an Iranian government overthrow.
Iran and Iraq were engaged in a deadly 10 year war (1980-89) where both sides used North Korean and Russian made SCUD rockets on each other's cities - with documented use of chemical agents by both sides. These folks are nasty critters who have used WMD on fellow believers. Do we infidels stand a chance of being spared?
The UN and "Old Europe" continue to dither on a political solution that can never work without a valid military threat or a viable, effective Intelligence effort working at a popular political upheaval to give Iran consequences for non-compliance.
The entire survival of the industrialized world depends on a successful outcome. To blame this crisis on a single American administration is nonsense. Iran's nuclear program has been in development since the fall of the Shah in the late 1970's. Every Presidential Administration - every Secretary of State since -- is complicit in Iran's current nuclear status!
Corsi's fault is to largely narrow his wrath on Bill Clinton and Madeline Halfbright's non-efforts. But, who can forget Iran-Contra and Ollie North's birthday cake meant for Iranian "moderates". What were they thinking? Certainly there is enough lunacy to go around without resorting to the base art of partisan politics showing favor to any one side.
One can only hope that Homeland Security, TSA, FBI, CIA, stays lucky on this one. I wondered the same thing about cockpit doors while viewing the Manhattan skyline with my family from the WTC in 1998...
For goodness sake everyone -- drop the rhetoric - read the book - publish your own thoughts - speak out intelligently. This IS a problem that must be solved! HOW to solve it is not as easy as it seems. Corsi, with all his faults has produced a book to make us think - but perhaps pegged too many folks political fun meters in the process.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No