Most Helpful Customer Reviews
24 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Lightning is my girl, July 10, 2004
This review is from: Auf Der Maur (Audio CD)
In the modern music scene, too often female pop singers are relabelled "rock." Here's the real thing: Melissa Auf Der Maur -- formerly of the Smashing Pumpkins and Hole -- debuts with a blast in "Auf Der Maur," pushing aside pop-rockers with her robust, bass-heavy rockers. It opens with a bang in the swoopy, searing, catchy "Lightning is My Girl," which adds a rather confusing spoken interlude before the sweeping buildup of "Followed the Waves." From there on, she gets into the cycling hard rocker "Real A Lie," the softer "Taste You," the bass-heaving roaring "Beast of Honor," and the playful rocker "I'll Be Anything You Want." It rounds off with the sprawling "I Need I Want I Will," which starts on an ominous gothic note, before falling into silence, and blossoming again. Listening to this album, it's not hard to see why Melissa Auf Der Maur was in the Smashing Pumpkins -- she has the heavy, roaring complexity that many other rockers could benefit from. There's an air of confidence around "Auf De Maur," which seems to come from Auf Der Maur's past experience, and her undeniable talent as a bassist and singer. Auf Der Maur has a solid voice that rises above her music. Don't expect her to do any vocal gymnastics, but her vocals are assured and confident, as if she's fully in tune with her music. Her songwriting needs lots of work ("Take one look at your cook/Feed yourself, I'm on a hook"), but it has some raw promise ("I'll see you in my dreams/Electrified and cherry red") and very evocative imagery. She was also the bassist in both the Smashing Pumpkins and Hole, so needless to say she plays a mean bass on her own album -- complex, dark, heavy, and sinuously flexible. Her old bandmate James Iha and Queens of the Stone Age's Josh Homme offer their own talents, with Homme cowriting and playing solid guitar, and Iha offering his talents to the solid "Head Unbound." Melissa Auf Der Maur's debut shows the polish of many years in other people's bands, but she's strong on her own two feet, in her own unique sound. An imperfect but solid debut, and one that promises good things yet to come.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One really profound album, January 12, 2004
By A Customer
After the likes of Hole and Smashing Pumpkins, Melissa Auf der Maur has known the ropes enough to crank out a mediocre record... better for anyone reading this, she cranked out a near perfect CD. There is definately a profound element of songwriting going on here, as Auf der Maur incorporates her songs to the guest performers such as Queens of the Stone Age's Nick O, Smashing Pumpkin's James Iha, Mariyln Manson's Twiggy, and A Perfect Circle's Paz Lenchantin just to name a few. Anyways, this album is absolutely incredible. It's a rock album for rock fans. Songs such as "Lightning Is My Girl", the first single "Followed The Waves", "Beasts of Honor", and "Realalie" all perfectly embody a rock alias, while the more subtle and emmotional numbers like "Taste You" and "Would If I could" completely blow you away with their song writing. Melissa has always been in the shadows of stage and attention hungry Courtney Love and Billy Corgan, but she has turned her experience with them into a better album than either could crank out. The closing number, "I Need, I Want, I Will" is the album's most haunting tune, the band jamming out while Auf der Maur sticking behind her signature bass guitar and telling a spoken word story over a perfectly conducted band. The only unneeded song on this is close to the end "Overpower Thee" where the album loses steam and will probably become the track most skip over not to lose the driving power inbetween two of the albums most powerful songs "Would If I Could" and "Skin Reciever". Buy this now. Tracklisting: 1.Lightning Is My Girl 2.Followed the Waves 3.Realalie 4.Head Unbound 5.Taste You 6.Beasts of Honor 7.I'll Be Anything 8.My Foggy Notion 9.Would If I Could 10.Overpower Thee 11.Skin Reciever 12.I Need, I Want, I Will
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Worth a Peek, December 11, 2004
This review is from: Auf Der Maur (Audio CD)
Okay, the lyrics are dumb, true, and rock history hasn't been kind to secondary members of famous groups trying to strike gold on their own (just ask Andrew Ridgely, Jane Wiedlin, or even George Harrison)--though this seems to be less true in alt rock (just ask Kim Deal or Dave Grohl)--so maybe Melissa Auf Der Maur, former Smashing Pumpkins and Hole bassist, has rock genre on her side. Auf Der Maur's debut is a potentially great hard rock/metal/alt record--part Zep (and, by default, part Heart--check out the "Barracuda"-riffed "Skin Reciever"), part Pixies (and, by default, part Breeders-check out Melissa's dead-on Kim Deal imitation on "Followed the Waves"), oh, and, of course, part Billy Corgan-70's-influenced arena hard rock. A handful of songs here do rock politely, but me, I'd like to see Melissa make the H.R. Geiger reference in the CD finale literal and bring this monster to life. Why not unleash the metal beast and let listeners be trampled underneath, begging Melissa for the forgiveness she apparently craves so much if you read her lyrics? Why not let Melissa's monotone yet girly voice fight against the onslaught of metal guitar chomp? I dunno, but can you imagine what a great record? I'd buy that CD. This CD, I like, but I'd also sell it for two bucks when the bank account ran dry and I needed beer money.
Standout Tracks: "Lightning is My Girl," "Followed the Waves," "Real a Lie," "Taste You"
For more reviews, visit http://unpaidrockcritic.typepad.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|