Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A comprehensive chronicle of an historic career., August 27, 1998
By A Customer
Fans of Joan Sutherland will welcome this book. The Australian soprano was, of course, one of the great singers of this century. Her career was a long and honorable one, throughout which she and her husband/colleague, Richard Bonynge, always strove to maintain the highest of vocal and musical standards. This book, her long- awaited autobiography, is subtitled, "A Prima Donna's Progress," and that is exactly what Sutherland gives us. Indeed, I cannot recall another singer's biography that gives so detailed an account of a career. Sutherland provides virtually a day-by-day record of what she sang, when, where and with whom, with occasional other incidents thrown in. One suspects that not a single operatic performance, recital, recording or television appearance has gone unmentioned. This is both the book's strength and its weakness. Often this autobiography reads as if Sutherland had simply opened up her old engagement calendars and scrap books and added some connecting prose. What we do not get is any real insight into what Joan Sutherland thought about any of this, nor do we get as much as we might like of personal anecdotes to flesh out the bare-bones facts. For example, other Sutherland biographies have given thorough accounts of that legendary first Lucia at Covent Garden in 1959. Here, we just get more of the same. One hoped for more from Sutherland herself. What was it like to work with Serafin? what did she learn from him? how did he rehearse and coach? Possibly, Sutherland's (by her own admission) notoriously bad memory prevented the inclusion of much information beyond what is in her own files and diaries. All the same, at times one feels exhausted and somewhat overwhelmed by the seemingly endless recitation of performances, recitals and recordings. In spite of the surfeit of factual information, one hungers for more personal insights into Sutherland's life. Surely, she was more than the sum total of her many engagements. But then, Sutherland has always been a very private person and, perhaps understandably, this book reflects that. Its tone is casual and breezy, leavened with flashes of humor, totally lacking in cattiness, and generous in praise of colleagues. In these respects, the book is a true reflection of the personality and character of its author. And perhaps the aforementioned sense of fatigue is deliberate. The author certainly gives a very clear sense of the enormous amount of sheer hard work involved in her career, and of the utter dedication and professionalism of Joan Sutherland and Richard Bonynge. Apparently, that is how they wish to be remembered, and it is a praiseworthy valedictory indeed.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A nice history book, if that's what you're looking for..., May 18, 2001
By A Customer
To be quite honest, I haven't finished reading the book. I am a big fan of the great Joan Sutherland, but the autobiography was not what I expected. As an aspiring singer, I was hoping that Dame Sutherland might write about any challenges that she may have encountered in her successful operatic career. Sutherland has an enormous voice and such a wide vocal range of any soprano that I've heard. It would have been wonderful if she had written about her voice lessons with her mother and how she came to attain an almost perfect technique (she's a dramatic coloratura, if you didn't know). (There is, of course, the very small chance that she was a natural and didn't have to work on her technique...but I doubt that).The book contains many facts and details about where and when she performed, but it does not convey what her life was like. There was no sense of her emotions or feelings throughout the first bit that I actually did read. From reading the other comments on this book, it seems that it didn't get much better thereafter (and I didn't miss much). How unfortunate. Perhaps one day a biographer might be able to re-create her life with the warmth and colour that make people interesting to read about.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Dull, dull, dull, July 6, 2001
By A Customer
Seeing Sutherland interviewed on television, I didn't expect much insight into her career from her -- her husband is clearly better at it. I had hoped that given time for reflection, something better than this would emerge. All that you really learn is how busy she was traveling here and there for engagements. It almost makes you believe that she wouldn't have had a career if hadn't been for Bonynge.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|