i ordered it for me because i don't wear much make up often so as soon as i got it, i started playing with it. so far, the eyeshadows are pretty good, goes on smoothly and seems to hold color pretty well. the lipgloss doesn't seem tacky or too oily, the color is pretty pigmented. i've got an olive undertone so i don't see too many of the shades working for me, but i'm sure others' mileage may vary. overall, i'm pretty content with it.
4 starts cause its a little bigger in size than we were expecting (thought still portable snuff to be carried along in ur purse. i bought this case for my niece and she absolutely loved it. it has all shades u typically need, its a lovely gift for teens.