Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This book meets the criteria for The Caldecott Medal, October 2, 1999
By A Customer
Patricia Polacco's picture book Babushka Baba Yaga should be nominated for the Randolph Caldecott Medal. By looking at the distinguished illustrations, readers can become involved in the story. The plot, which can easily be understood by children ages four to eight, is interesting and wonderful. Baba Yaga is portrayed as a scary creature that lives in the forest. Although people who live in the village tell horrifying stories of her to children, Baba Yaga is really a kind and lonely individual. Furthermore, she longs to be a grandmother and hold a child in her arms. She disguises herself as a Babushka and becomes the caretaker of the little boy, Victor. Baba Yaga becomes close with the child and the two develop a strong love for one another. Young children can relate to Baba Yaga's experience and even sympathize for her loneliness as an outsider of the village. Consequently, the main conflict of person verses society is revealed in Polacco's book. Through illustrations, this theme is displayed effectively. Baba Yaga is shown from the outside looking in at the people. We get a sense of her desire for a grandchild as her face is drawn with dark gray, green and brown. Her face is sad looking and the use of color helps the reader get a sense of the mood. Polacco states "And so she watched sadly from afar as people of the nearby village celebrated the season of their lives together." Hence, the illustrations accurately correspond with the content of the story. The theme of the story is great and beneficial to children. In addition, the theme ties into the plot, characters, and setting of the book. Children are taught the lesson not to form an opinion of people based on their physical appearance. Also this powerful use of characterization allows the reader to see Baba Yaga as a kind and loving individual. As children learn a valuable lesson that appearance is only skin deep, and what really matters is what is inside a person, they will gain a collective unity from this book. Through the themes, concept, and bright pictures, this book is great for children. Polacco understands the abilities of children and incorporated well-developed illustrations with an effective content with makes this an excellent educational story for children. Furthermore picture book meets the criteria and terms of the Caldecott Award.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Who's afraid of the big bad babushka?, June 29, 2004
This review is from: Babushka Baba Yaga (Mass Market Paperback)
Authors (especially authors of children's books) love reinterpreting old folk and fairy tales. From "The Stinky Cheese Man" to "East", children are constantly being exposed to a wide variety of new ways of reading and interpreting the tales they heard when younger. Patricia Polacco is to be commended for her particularly original reinterpretation. Some of you may be familiar with the classic Baba Yaga stories that came out of Russia. These stories centered on an evil old woman who lived in a house that stood on chicken legs. Usually portrayed as a wicked witch, Baba Yaga ate children and cavorted with the darkest of magics. In "Babushka Baba Yaga", Polacco reclaims a newly misunderstood icon. Unlike the stories, the Baba Yaga in this tale is the last of her kind. Terribly lonely in her forest home, she spends the days enviously spying on the grandmothers (or "babushkas") of the nearby village. There is nothing Baba Yaga would like more than to care for a little young creature of her own. One day she has the idea of borrowing some babushka clothing and arriving in the village as an old woman. It isn't long before she meets Natasha and her little son Victor. Victor has no babushka of his own, and Baba Yaga offers to take care of the boy, cook, and clean in exhange for a bed and some food. Things go swimmingly for quite a while. Then, one day, Victor and his new babushka overhear a chilling Baba Yaga tale and the boy is greatly scared. Not wanting to cause any trouble, Baba Yaga leaves the happy home with great sorrow. It's only through a miraculous rescue and the villagers' acceptance that things are finally put to rights at the end. The moral of the story is spoken by one of the village women at the book's finish. "Those who judge one another on what they hear or see, and not on what they know of them in their hearts, are fools indeed!" I especially ask that you consider the book's final picture. There, Baba Yaga hugs a happy Victor, his chubby hands clutching her and wiping his face. Polacco has always excelled at books that make adult readers cry. I have no doubts at all that this story falls squarely into that category. After all, this is a tale about gaining the love of little children, regardless of age or background. The text is especially clever and is well accompanied by Polacco's clever illustrations. If you're not partial to Polacco pictures then I'm certain you won't much care for this book. If, on the other hand, you are charmed by her sometimes slapdash sometimes intricately shaded pictures you'll be in seventh heaven. Faces are her forte, and in the book Baba Yaga is lined and creased, as are the faces of all the older women in the village. There is tenderness found in these people, and it comes as much from their actions as from their gently rounded cheeks. "Babushka Baba Yaga" embraces the idea of the "true" Baba Yaga. When reading scary folktales, consider adding this book to your repertoire. It successfully combines the old and the young with the ancient and the post-modern. A delightful enjoyable story, easily read again and again.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A wonderful book to share with young readers!, November 23, 1998
By A Customer
This is a wonderful story that my children absolutely love!!! It is a poignant reminder that people can be very cruel to those they deem different, but that there is beauty within each and every person if you look hard enough. My children were able to relate to the characters in the story and speak of Babushka Baba Yaga as though she is a real person. Although the story is set in Russia, the experience does not have any geographic boundaries and can spark many lively day-to-day questions from a young child. The story touches on issues that children need to be reminded of: showing that beauty is only skin deep, being kind to all people, just because you're different doesn't mean it's bad, giving everyone a chance, etc. Other stories that have had the same effect on my children are Stellaluna, Guess How Much I Love You, The Giving Tree, and more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|