Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of my favorite YA books!, December 11, 2006
This review is from: Babyface (Paperback)
At 14, Toni Chessmore considers herself pretty lucky. Dubbing it "Toni Luck," she's always had a great life: two parents that dote upon her, best friend Julie living right next door. Her days are even filled with tiny bits of luck, such as finding money on the ground and being coincidentally at the right place to land a good summer job.
Although she tries not to, Toni can't help but feel a bit superior to others. Julie, for example, has always had such a miserable family life. Even Toni's much-older sister Martine seems so unhappy. Is it Toni's fault that she can't really relate?
Then Toni's father suffers a heart attack, and everything changes. While her parents attend a healthy-living workshop in another state, Toni goes to stay with Martine, the sister who left home when she was just a baby. It's then that Toni begins to learn the reasons for Martine's coldness, reasons she herself could never have begun to suspect.
When the truth comes out, is Toni really any better off than Julie? Is it better to know or not to know?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
cute, lightweight read, meant for the younger audience, July 21, 2011
Fifteen year old Toni Chessmore has it all, a family that loves her, a best friend who lives right next door, but nothing in life is perfect right? Her best friend has to go to California for summer due to some sad circumstances, Toni falls for the boy that her best friend was crushing on, and finds out a family secret that has been buried for years.
This book was very short, in fact it's under 200 pages. I feel like maybe if I read this book when I was younger like 12-13 I probably would have enjoyed it more, but because of the fact that i've read so many more complex novels before this one, it feel short for me. Norma Fox Mazer was a favorite author of mine growing up and After The Rain, is one of those books that stick out in my mind that made me fall in love with reading from the beginning, and It won a number of awards to boot.
I think the younger audience would really enjoy this book, it's a light-hearted, summer read, that deals with issues that probably anyone could be able to relate too or have been through similar situations when they were younger. Norma Fox Mazer will continue to be an author I check out but this book was a little too basic and lacked complexity that i'm used too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
When nothing is as it seems, June 23, 2011
Fourteen-year-old Toni Chessmore thinks her life is just about perfect. Her parents dote on her, and she has a fantastic relationship with her best friend, Julie. In fact, Toni's house is Julie's refuge when her parents' arguing gets out of control. When Julie's mother takes her away for the summer, Toni can't imagine things getting any worse. Then her father has a heart attack, and while her mother helps him through a recovery program, Toni goes to stay with her much older sister Martine, a near-stranger with a brusque manner. One night, Martine tells Toni a secret about their oh-so-happy family . . . and Toni knows right away that nothing will ever be the same again.
This is a wise, nuanced little novel, full of richly drawn characters and deeply revealing subplots. Mazer handles Toni's transition from sheltered little girl to sensitive and aware young woman with grace and skill. Toni is a thoroughly likable and believable character, and her turmoil is genuine and poignant.
I will admit I didn't entirely understand why the secret Toni learned was such a big deal, but then again, she's more the protected innocent at the age of fourteen than I was at four. It's not the secret itself that makes such a difference in Toni's life as the understanding that some aspects of her "perfect" life are not what she thought they were. More problematic for me was the ending, which is hopeful, but rather too pat: all of a sudden in the last chapter everything works out all at once. Had the same resolution been brought about more gradually, it would have been much more believable and satisfying. That said, however, this is an enjoyable and mature novel that should have great appeal to young readers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|