Most Helpful Customer Reviews
246 of 252 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing., December 7, 2006
This review is from: Bach Edition: Complete Works (155 CD Box Set) (Audio CD)
This is an amazing bargain, and if you are tempted you need not hesitate. However it is far from uniformly excellent.
The core of the set is the complete religious cantatas. There are 60 cd of these. This is done by a small Dutch group, and the results are mixed. The choir is generally good, as is the small orchestra, but sometimes the soloists are not. I like them overall. Above all they are small scale performances. Don't expect John Elliot Gardiner.
With the major vocal works -- passions, B minor, etc -- the recordings are uniformly good, with usually big name groups. No worries here. The secular cantatas are also very good.
The harpsichord music is again a bit uneven, but mostly good. This won't be a favorite WTC, but it is quite listenable. The French, Englis suites, and partitas & inventions are very good indeed. The recorded sound is outstanding throughout.
The organ survey is first rate.
The instrumental music is also a mixed bag. The chamber music fares better than the orchestral, but the suites are quite good. The harpsichord concerti are beautifully recorded but at such a slow tempo I can only call them weird.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
154 of 160 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Definitely worth the price, which factors into the rating, February 10, 2007
This review is from: Bach Edition: Complete Works (155 CD Box Set) (Audio CD)
[...]This Bach set is an amazing bargain. Clearly the set is geared towards the novice and you'll want to replace individual performances eventually; but much of this material is difficult or impossible to get elsewhere (except as part of one of the two other Complete Bach cycles), and you'd be unlikely to anyway. Plus, there are many very good performances, which alone would make the set worthwhile at this price.
As far as I am concerned, the Hanssler Classics complete set is the best of the complete sets. I've reviewed that one separately. However, it is ten times more expensive, if you can even find it. Your other choice, the Bach 2000 set, contains the Leonhardt-Harnoncourt cycle of Cantatas, which I cannot stand. I agree with Jim Svejda when he noted that Harnoncourt and Leonhards "gleefully take turns mauling the luckless pieces beyond recognition."
One of the saddest facts of musical history is that Bach was not recognized for the genius that he was in his lifetime. His compositions were mostly occasional music that were played once. After his death, they were so little respected that much of the sheet music was sold for scrap paper and about a third of the Cantatas were lost forever. Fortunately we have what we do. That Brilliant Classics has made this wonderful music available at a price that allows a more widespread distribution makes it reason enough to purchase the set.
Brilliant Classics attempted to record the entirety of Bach's remaining compositions on period instruments utilizing the most recent Bach scholarship. 65% of the set are new recordings. The other 35% were licensed from other lables. Now some, like me, much prefer the recordings on modern instruments. I have yet to hear a harpsichord rendition of the Goldberg Variations that is superior to the top performances on piano (although it is a well-known fact that Bach hated the piano, which during his lifetime was little more than a toy). All of the keyboard works on this set are recorded on harpsichord. Pieter-Jan Belder records that Goldberg Variations. It has received fine reviews, but I simply cannot get beyond my prejudices against the harpsichord to comment meaningfully (it is quite lively, though).
That said, and with the reservation that this set is performed with nearly all period instruments, I can recommend it without hesitation at this price.
The Brilliant Classics set has an interesting history. It is based on 5-disc sets of the Cantatas sold at the Krudivat drug store chain in the Netherlands at bargain basement prices (the equivalent of pennies per Cantata). More than 100,000 sets were sold in the Netherlands alone. Pieter Jan Leusink, conductor of Holland Boys Choir and Netherlands Bach Collegium, recorded the Cantatas over a period of 15 months, an insanely short period of time. It is the first digital recording of the Cantatas. There is a consistency of performers in this cycle that is unrivaled, although not all of the performers performed at the same time. Also I find the women singers on the Rilling cycle of Cantatas better than anything a choir of boys can do, despite the unhistorical aspect of such. I doubt that female singers would have shocked Bach--after all, he married one. An interview with Leusink regarding the cycle can be found online.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
142 of 155 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful, November 22, 2006
This review is from: Bach Edition: Complete Works (155 CD Box Set) (Audio CD)
I will not give it 5 stars because they are not all definitive recordings of the works. However, I was very surprised with the performance level of the entire set. The organ works are amazing as are the cantatas! And I don't mean good... I mean really good! Some of the harpsichord recordings sound like someone sight reading (and not all that well), and lack that fresh excitement of a truly great recording but they are technically accurate for the most part (tempos tend to get a little shaky around difficult passages and phrase endings, something that is not written in the music) See the Well-Tempered Clavier in this set to see what I am talking about. There are a few other flaws... Mainly in recording... For example (I'll take a popular work): The organ fugue in G minor BWV 578 "Little Fugue" is surrounded with noises... Almost like the sound of footsteps on a stage (see 1:06, 2:29, 2:53 and 2:39 in this piece). However, I believe it is the sound of the air pump re-filling the organ with air! Very cool for authenticity and period sound... Definitely not needed for these recordings. We get the point with the instrumentation; I don't need an auditory time machine to recreate the moment in full. Next they will add the sounds of the people in the church chatting in 18th century German. Please... Just the music! I am glad that the recordings are all done with period instruments though and great care (almost too much) was taken in authenticity. Don't get me wrong; I didn't toss out my Andras Schiff Inventions or my modern orchestra versions of his works. Quite the contrary... You can learn a lot about the music by listening to all versions. That's not a shot at the purists... Well, maybe it is. I mean if you only had period versions of Beethoven's symphonies, he would be trampled over by Mahler, Bruckner and the rest of the gang. That's a fact. But in the case of Bach, it is almost essential that you maintain the original instrumentation. Bach's music is so based on the relationship between voices and the subtlest of contrapuntal ideals. He is not a sculptor of sound, as Mozart, Beethoven and Brahms were, but more like a musical acrobat that can do summersaults on a wire an inch thick.
I could go into details, but it would take hundreds of pages! Just get it, and "spend the rest of your life with Bach"... I can't say anything more profound.
This set of 155 CDs is a true delight, and a great investment for the dedicated music fan. Plus, it looks awesome on your CD shelf.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
