As a previous reviewer noted, Fischer decided to take the outer movements faster than is typical. For me, this meant that, after beginning to listen to the brisk first movement of the D minor Double, it wasn't quite love at first listen. The ear can rebel against what it's not used to. However, I soon came to appreciate Fischer's approach and style, and I became a fan of this disc. I found the E major in particular -- a piece you might think you know all too well -- to be unexpectedly exciting, and, in the slow movement, just gorgeous. The danger with speed on these is that one risks sapping them of their inherent drama and beauty. Some self-consciously period-correct recordings I've heard fall into this trap, and the result is awfully noisy and unattractive. Fischer and her fellow performers, with this non-period recording, avoid this pitfall with perfect precision, balance, and appropriately restrained, just-right sensitivity.
Fischer says in the liner notes that she is seeking to emphasize a neglected virtuosic aspect to these concertos -- hence the speed -- but also to blend with the ensemble where appropriate, and not to indulge in romantic affect, which can be tempting because some of this music -- the slow movement of the D minor Double in particular -- is very beautiful. All of this bespeaks an intelligent and distinctive approach that successfully walks the line between respect for period style and the the nature of the music on the one hand, and the undeniable fact that, as she says, this is being played for 21st century ears on the other. Fischer seems to be saying, you're allowed to have fun and be creative and impressive with these, but this is still Bach, so keep your wits about you.
It makes sense that Fischer would approach the music in this way. If you're already familiar with Fischer, I don't need to say that she's not just the hot soloist of the moment with dazzling technical chops, but a thoughtful and mature musician as well, characterized by fidelity, sensitivity, and uncanny control in the service of the music. With this disc, these qualities that make her the one to watch are on full display, and it's well worth adding to the shelf, whether as a supplement to other recordings you may have, an introduction to these essential works, or as a new go-to standard. If we were in the days of LP's, I'd already be wearing mine out! Enjoy.