4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
weirdness made compelling and finally lovable, September 10, 2010
First, there IS no one who writes like Henry Green, and it is hard to describe the experience of reading him. He has his own cadences, both in words and phrasing, and in the passing of time. It is as if one has entered another universe, but one that is more firmly our own. It is not realism, except that it makes you feel piercing intense emotions that feel too real to bear.
Second, he isn't for everyone. I knew my husband wouldn't like it because the main character cannot expresses his emotions at the beginning, and cannot by the end. Also I gave my husband an outline of the plot, and he said, "But that is just too ridiculously unbelievable."
Then, just after I finished reading the book, I picked up the book my husband was reading, Roth's "American Pastoral," started reading it, and thought, wait, is this Henry Green I am reading? It sounds just like him. No doubt there are unexplored similarities between Roth and Green, but what I think was happening was that Green's voice is simply so all-encompassingly strong, that at that moment anything I picked up would have sounded like Green.
So it is great because it makes you see the world anew, I mean, that is a cliche of greatness that he does pull off, but what is it here that we see here? For me, an appreciation of the effects of war on the men caught up in it, even though the book only gives ever one small detail of the 4 years Charley has spent in a German prisoner-of-war camp. A feeling for how much confusion can be brought to us by love that doesn't work out as we would wish, and of the sheer stubbornness of the brain when it doesn't want to accept things.
It's also about how a writer can create characters out of bits and scraps, and we soon start rooting for them. But then it turns around and we see we are all just made up of bits and scraps.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Roses around the headstones, May 14, 2009
Two quick but more or less final conclusions on finishing this quietly devastating English novel from 1946: You are never once allowed to forget that you are reading words intricately and even eccentrically arranged by the inimitable Henry Green. Yet the quixotically deranged character of one-legged Charley Summers is rendered so vividly and so indelibly as to make the writing appear all but invisible.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No