Customer Reviews

Baker's Secret Basics 3-Piece Cookie Sheet Value Pack

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(7)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(5)

 

 

OK, this set comes with 3 cookie sheets of differing sizes, which are thick and non-stick, and all for under $15 with free shipping! You can't go wrong with that! I've used cookie sheets purchased at upscale cooking stores where one cookie sheet costs more than this whole set, and honestly, I can't see a difference in the results. Conversely, I have purchased similar sets at bargain stores for similar prices, and the quality has been lacking (non-stick coating scrapes away, sheets warp during baking, etc.) Though I haven't had this Baker's Secret set very long, so far its quality appears high. I would recommend it!

The old baking sheet I had was big and dented. I always had to grease the pan before baking. Now it is so easy and light weight and my cookies slide right off the pan! Terrific!

I usually go to a Mass Marketing store to get my pans, and decided to try these out.
The price is less than I usually pay.

I ordered two sets, and I lOVE Them!

Three different sizes for different needs. They clean easily. No stains on mine yet, and it's been four months.

I'll definately buy again, IF mine ever wear out.

They are working well so far. They stain a little when grease gets on them.

These are great cookie sheets for the price. I paid $10 at a local supermarket. You do not need to grease them before baking. They do stain a little but you can't beat the price.

I have used the three different sized trays before but they were over 15 years old. So far the new ones at least will make what I cook look better.
A good buy!

This is a replacement set for an old set that I'd had for about 10 years! Baker's Secret pans are great to work with, their non-stick surface is excellent, and very easy to clean up when done. I've made a few dozen cookies in these pans already and nothing has stuck to them. I'm very pleased.

Decent pans nothing fancy, wish they were a tad more heavy duty. But hey you get what you pay for.

These are fantastic, you don't have to use a lot of non-stick spray and they haven't warped at all!

This 3-piece set is all you'll probably need for your regular baking purposes, and then some. A small pan, a medium, and a large come in this set, covering pretty much all your oven needs right there. Each pan is super sturdy, so you're not dealing with any flimsy, easily broken products in this package, and the non-stick surface means you won't have to worry very much about stains or food clinging to trays, either, so you can use less parchment paper or cooking spray.

The only issue: even the BOTTOMS are non-stick. So when you place it in the oven, watch out. It may just slide all the way to the back, sloshing around everything on it by accident. Same on the counter top; I almost saw my pan of cookies slide across the kitchen counter like a mug of beer slung down the bar at Cheers. Watch out, Norm!

It's a minor quibble, and once you get past it you're getting three great pans for not a lot of money. It's no "Baker's Secret" to me, these cooking sheets are fantastic.