11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Shockingly great access, footage and narrative, September 12, 2005
This review is from: Balseros (DVD)
"Balseros" is movie of deep commitment executed by a team of heavily talented reporters and film professionals. The work effort covers a period of almost eight years, starting with the so-called "Balseros" crisis of 1994, when - in shades of the Mariel Boatlift in 1980 - a policy shift by Fidel's government sends thousands of industrious Cubans streaming towards the shores of Florida.
The access the film team has to the island is unprecedented. You see the rafts being crafted and carried through the streets. When protagonist Guillermo Armas rides to the shore with this raft, he's cordoned by a wave of joyous bicyclists. What an amazing scene. In the meantime, the camera captures the seedy and rundown nature of present-day Havana.
Where "Balseros" stands apart is in carrying the film through to 2001, when we see what has become of the seven protagonists. You have to give immense credit to co-directors and writers Carles Bosch & Josep Domènech for the effort and skill in putting together this tale.
And, in a film with standout moments, here's mine: the team takes to the waters to document the journeys. At times, it encounters hauntingly empty rafts. The voice over gently tells you about the implications of an empty raft. All you have to do is juxtapose the flimsiness of some of these vessels vs. the raging currents in the straits and it's not difficult to imagine how these journeys came to a ghostly end.
Good complements to "Balseros" are "Finding Mañana" Mirta Ojito's outstanding 2005 memoir of the the Mariel Boatlift, Reinaldo Arenas' "Before Night Falls" (acclaimed author Arenas also came over in Mariel) and "Azucar Amarga," another great film with outstanding live footage (spliced into a compelling fictional story).
The movie follows seven specific protagonists. I found it hard to distinguish the threads at times, but Spanish producer Bausan Films has an outstanding press package on its web site and it contains a little cheat sheet of the seven, which I'm pasting in here because I think it'll really help your watching of the film:
MÉRICYS GONZALEZ
HER JOURNEY
AUGUST 1994
Builds a raft in Havana
SEPTEMBER 1994
She sets off to sea. The raft is wrecked and she returns to Cuba
FIVE YEARS LATER 2001
She obtains a legal visa and goes to Albuquerque, New Mexico to join her sister
OSCAR DEL VALLE
HIS JOURNEY
AUGUST 1994
Builds a raft in Havana
SEPTEMBER 1994
Goes to sea and in U.S. waters is picked up and sent to the naval base at Guantanamo
OCTOBER/DECEMBER 1995
Accepted in the U.S.A. he is sent to the Bronx
FIVE YEARS LATER 2001
He has moved to York (Pennsylvania)
RAFAEL CANO
HIS JOURNEY
AUGUST 1994
Builds a raft and is thrown out of it
SEPTEMBER 1994
In a "new" raft he sets out to sea and is detained in U.S. waters. He is taken to Guantanamo
OCTOBER/DECEMBER 1995
Accepted into the U.S. he is sent to Miami
JUNE 1996
He goes to Nebraska
FIVE YEARS LATER 2001
The TV program broadcast nationally from Miami, Gran Impacto, sets out to find him
MÍRIAM HERNÁNDEZ
HER JOURNEY
AUGUST 1994
Builds a raft in Batabanó (in southern Cuba)
SEPTEMBER 1994
She sets out to sea and is detained in U.S. waters and sent to the naval base in Guantanamo
OCTOBER/DECEMBER 1995
Accepted in the U.S. she is sent to Miami
FIVE YEARS LATER 2001
She is still waiting for her daughter, who is now eight years old, and who Miriam still has not been able to bring from Cuba
GUILLERMO ARMAS
HIS JOURNEY
AUGUST 1994
Builds a raft in Havana
SEPTEMBER 1994
Sets out to sea and is detained in U.S. waters and sent to the naval base at Guantanamo
MAY 1995
Accepted in the U.S. he is sent to Miami
FIVE YEARS LATER 2001
He lives with his wife and daughter in Miami
JUAN CARLOS AND MISCLAIDA
THEIR JOURNEYS
AUGUST 1994
They build a raft in Havana
SEPTEMBER 1994
They set out to sea and are detained in U.S. waters and sent to the naval base at Guantanamo
OCTOBER/DECEMBER 1995
Accepted in the U.S. they are sent to Granby, Connecticut
FIVE YEARS LATER 2001
They have separated. He lives in Granby. She lives in Albuquerque, New Mexico.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the best documentaries on migration, June 18, 2007
This review is from: Balseros (DVD)
The movie documents the lives of half a dozen Cubans as they struggle to escape their wretched lives to reach the land of dreams. Seen in a braoder context, I could immediately relate to the hopes and aspirations of people in various corners of the third world as they seek to make a home in the West.
Most interesting was to note how fragile human relationships are - majority of these 6 Cubans who finally make it to America find loving and living with people against all promises made to loved ones when departing. Since this documentary tracks the lives of these people across several years, it provides a rich historical context to measure the reality against the dreams that these immigrants had when departing for America.
Thankfully, the movie stays away from any political overtones (as in Castro-bashing, or America/ CIA bashing).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
