13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very involved!, June 10, 2003
By A Customer
I've been religiously keeping up with Margaret Haddix's Shadow Children series ever since I picked up Among the Hidden in the library about three years ago.
The series has been getting more involved and intricate, and Among the Barons is easily *the* most intricate of the current set of four.
In the other three novels Luke's (or Nina's, in the third book) problems are pretty straightforward by comparison - their actions revolve around achieving specific goals that don't involve too much political intrigue, which, I find, always introduces more complexity in novels because other characters' motivations and thoughts become equally important as the main character's, and not just of secondary importance; an example of this is the contrast between Mr. Talbot's interactions with Luke (and Luke occasionally questions his faith in Mr. Talbot) and Oscar's interactions with Luke (where Luke's decisions start to affect other people).
So, in Among the Barons, Luke has to deal with problems of greater difficulty - there's some people who show up who really don't care much about Luke and would as soon see him gone in one way or another.
The book also fleshes out some of the chronology and politics that make up the back story of the Shadow Children series; it introduces the first organized rebel movement as well as actual Barons besides just Mr. Talbot, and the Barons often act self-centered and arrogant, which is a change from the humanistic Mr. Talbot.
Interestingly, Luke continues to follow a kind of "middle path"; he never wholly commits himself one way or another, and this adds a great deal of depth to Luke's character, and makes him more real. For example, he chooses a different way to achieve Jen's goal; one that suits his naturally cautious nature - instead of vocally organizing protest rallies and attracting the attention of the Government (which is ready to shoot first and ask questions later if the wrong people are crossed), he chooses to hide in plain sight, adopting the identity of a Baron. Later, when asked to move on from Hendricks, Luke decides he wants to improve his education and understanding before accepting Mr. Talbot's offer. And finally, in Among the Barons (can't spoil too much of the plot here), he does not wholly take sides with the rebel movement, but finds himself drawn into confusion over whose methods will accomplish the goal - Mr. Talbot's of working from within, or Oscar's of fighting from without? The book doesn't leave this clear-cut (although Luke's faith in Mr. Talbot's method isn't shaken), and I suspect the next book will probably show Luke's further evolution in this matter.
It's easy to imagine another person in the Shadow Children universe being a die-hard member of a nonviolent populist movement aiming to bring about political change, but this would reduce that person to a fairly flat character since the ideology puts constraints on what actions and thoughts are believable for the character.
Incidentally, Jen Talbot, had she lived, could well have been on her way to being such a leader; burning with desire to right wrongs, but not given to violence in her makeup, she could well have founded or risen to the top of such a populist movement in the Shadow Children universe.
Good book! I look forward to the upcoming books in this series. (The 4 stars rather than 5 is because of some minor nitpicks about the degree to which Smits gets his way in the school.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Book That You Won't Want To Put Down, August 1, 2003
Margaret Peterson Haddix's book Among the Barons is simply amazing! Being the 4th book in the series about "shadow children" it keeps you guessing till the very end. Believe me, once you pick up this book you won't wan't to put it down. Haddix's writing makes you feel like you're actually in the story! All in all this book is a have to read , never wan't to put down book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Among the Barons, March 31, 2004
Among the Barons
By: Margaret Peterson Haddix
Reviewed by: J. Fujii
Period: 5
Among the Barons by Margaret Peterson Haddix is the fourth book in the series of shadow books. The book is about a third child named Luke Gardner who gets a fake i.d. to become Lee Grant. Luke attends Hendricks School for Boys. After six months, Lee's real brother, Smits, goes to Luke's school. Smits arrives at Hendricks in a limo and he has a bodyguard named Oscar. Luke shows his "brother" Smits around Hendricks. Smits acts like the schoool which is a special school for the barons class isn't fancy. Smits tries to get Oscar fired because Smits doesn't want a bodyguard. Smits starts a fire in Hendricks and blames Oscar. After the fire, Luke finds two fake i.d. cards. They cause him to wonder who they belong to. In the meantime, Smits, Luke and Oscar go home to the Grants' house because the Grants say that want to watch over their children. Luke meets Mr. and Mrs. Grant and goes to Lee's room which is clean and very organized. Around midnight, the Grants talk to Luke about staging his death as Lee because the Grants are being blackmailed for Lee's illegal activities. On that same night, Oscar wakes up Luke and tells him about a secret resistance force that is fighting against the Barons. The Grants die when a huge chandelier falls on them. Luke then takes Smits home to his own family and Smits begins to live with Luke's family.
I enjoyed this book because I like science fiction. I also liked this book because it had some humor. A humorous line is when a boy said, "The new boy brought 4 suitcases, his own computer and a giant TV."
I also liked this book because it keeps you reading. For instance, when Oscar says, "Watch out for the chandelier," it made me want to keep reading to find out what was going to happen with the chandelier. The author made me want to read on and it was surprising to find out what happens next to Luke.
My favorite part of the story was when Smits comes to Hendricks. I liked this part because Smits was a man in a boys' body because he acted like a businessman. It was also my favorite part because of all the rumors being spread about Smits such as his reported gourmet meals being sent in from a restaurant in a city 1 hour away from the school.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No