From School Library Journal
Grade 3-6–Bartleby, a red-eared turtle, and his alligator friend, Seezer, have traveled through three seasons to make their way from their former lives as pets in New York State to their rightful home in bayou country. Sadly, when they arrive, the bayou is not as Seezer remembers it, nor as Bartleby imagined it. A huge and nasty gator, Old Stump, and his gang of four have taken over the area and eaten or frightened away most of the other animals. Bartleby is as courageous and clever as he was when he met Seezer in
Bartleby of the Mighty Mississippi (Dutton, 2000) and he manages to outwit the numerous enemies he encounters in the swamp. Finally he meets other red-ears, as he has longed to do since he saw a nature special in his former home, and finds his match in plucky Lucky Gal. Friends and foes interact much like people and discover loyalties and harmony after surviving drought, bullies, and another spell in captivity. Fans of the first book will enjoy this story most but it can stand on its own. Touching and exciting, this fast and easy read will appeal even to reluctant readers.
–Susan Oliver, Tampa-Hillsborough Public Library System, FL Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 4-6. In a worthy follow-up to
Bartleby of the Mighty Mississippi (2000), Shalant relates the adventures of the gentle-souled but resourceful red-ear turtle who has gone back to his roots. With his alligator friend, Seezer, Bartleby has managed to make it all the way from a New York pond to the bayou, only to find an unwelcoming committee of garfish and hostile alligators. The bayou's turtles are not very friendly, either, except for one with a damaged webbed foot named Lucky Gal. From here loyalties shift, unlikely alliances are forged, and daring rescues are made. In the end comes a true and satisfying homecoming. The story entertains as it informs. The bayou critters think and talk like ornery human beings, but Shalant also transmits substantial information about the eating, sleeping, and gathering habits of various species. The bayou becomes a model for how different personalities can learn to get along. In an amusing side note, sensitive, empathetic Bartleby comes to understand what a sweet, inarticulate urban dog is trying to say.
Abby NolanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved