From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3–As in the author's
Princess Prunella and the Purple Peanut (Workman, 1995) and
Rude Ramsey and the Roaring Radishes (Bloomsbury, 2004), sophisticated wordplay drives this story. Bob was abandoned beside a beauty parlor as a baby. Raised by three dogs, he barked when bothered and would bound behind bushes or burrow under benches. A block away, Dorinda has problems of her own. Dumped on distant relatives when her parents disappeared, she has lived a Cinderella-like existence, dealing with dirty dishes in a disreputable dive. When Dorinda meets up with Bob, she teaches him how to talk, and together they thwart the advances of a bewildered buffalo wrongly labeled a begonia by a bungling bureaucrat. The simultaneous exploits of the characters are shown in Petricic's line drawings. Color is used to great effect–Bob's scenes have a muddy gold wash and Dorinda's are rendered in purple. The witty, albeit ridiculous plot plays not only with language, but also with fairy-tale conventions. However, despite the happy ending, the relentless alliteration becomes tiresome.
–Linda Ludke, London Public Library, Ontario, Canada Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Great for reading aloud, this fractured fairy tale retells the Cinderella foundling story with wild wordplay and lovely, playful line-and-watercolor illustrations. Abandoned as a baby by his bubble-headed mom, Bob is raised by dogs in a vacant lot. Doleful Dorinda's parents disappear in a dreadful disaster, dumping her with despicable relatives dripping with diamonds. They make her drudge from dawn to dusk . . . until she departs and befriends Bob; together they prove themselves brave and daring. Finally, their parents find them, and they all live together in "blinding bliss, delirious with delicious delight." Unlike many adults who write for kids, Atwood isn't condescending; alliteration is a big part of the fun, and the pictures, in shades of mauve (for Dorinda) and brown (for Bob), give the brave children a distinctive look.
Hazel RochmanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved