Customer Reviews

Basic Judaism (Harvest Book.)

5 star:		(12)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Back in the 'Eighties, I found myself teaching Chaim Potok's "The
Chosen" to a Year 12 class, a system-shock, since I was, by then,
as school librarian, largely free from classroom duties. But it was a
book I liked, and the best book, by far, on that year's required
reading list, and the English Coordinator, the class teacher, had
declared himself an avid antisemetic and thus unwilling to add the
text to his repertoire..though quite willing to allow ME to
"borrow" his class to demonstrate the book's worth.And so I
came to research Judaism the first time..

The second thrust toward
Judaic enlightenment was differently inspired, prompted, in fact, by a
stroll around New Orleans with a Jewish met-on-the- internet-friend
from New York, with me miserably aware that I was registering only a
fraction of his conversational vocabulary (and that several paragraphs
behind). And it seemed to me that if so obviously intelligent a man
could find meaning in Judaism, perhaps the faith,and its inherent
disciplines, were worth a second look..

But where to look
first?
Other Jewish friends proffered advice.
Herman Wouk's
"This Is My God" was recommended.

"Lightweight!" scoffed my New York friend."Pap for the
masses!You would do better just asking ME!"



But I wanted to
input some other, more openminded ideas, and tried Amazon Books.

Amazon came up with a list of twenty or more, a list which threatened
to go on, and on, but I started with nine, the shelf since much
augmented, and browsed them all, before selecting "Basic
Judaism",by Rabbi Milton Steinberg, subtitled :
"The
essential book for both Jews and non-Jews eager to know more about one
of the world's great religions".



And as a starting point,
as an overview, as a balanced, heart-warming, conscious-of-all-faiths
introduction to the Jewish way of life, I doubt you can go past Rabbi
Steinberg's positive little text which manages, in just 172 pages, to
render the seemingly impenetrable, quite translucent... sunlit, even!


Educated in my formative years by Sisters Of Joseph nuns,
indoctrinated that only baptised Christians can "enter the
Kingdom Of Heaven", I was unprepared for the welcoming warmth
this little book exudes. There is no hint of a restricted heaven here,
nor babies in limbo, with Rabbi Steinberg reminding us, over and over,
that , to a Jew, heaven is for the righteous, all righteous
,regardless of creed, something my Islam-convert son has pointed out
to me as a major difference, also, between Christianity and his
adopted faith.
I was interested, too, to see that there is no
equivalent of the Catholic Pope, and no parent "CHURCH" to
grow rich and powerful, that each synagogue congregation is an
independent, autonymous entity..
Interested,too, to see how much
emphasis Judaism places on individual learning and scholarship, even
for women,and on rights for women, NOT things the Christian churches
have exactly emphasised down the years.



As well, Rabbi Steinberg
continually clarifies both the traditionalist and modernist Jewish
stances on each point at issue...something else that came as something
of a shock to me after my rather frustrating attempts at broadbased
discussion with my classically trained, Ashkenazic Jewish friend from
New York.



But remember, this is an OVERVIEW of Judaism, and not
the book in which to delve for obscure points of pre-Passover
procedure, though its eleven sections cover Judaism from historical
foundations , through current practice, to a "World To Come"
section and Epilogue, noting, at each step, the differences in
interpretation between the main Jewish divisions, and explaining how
these interpretations affect daily life for a Jew.

I have read
many books on Judaism since, and attended classes, and "discussed
the Holy Books" with some very learned men indeed, and had many
questions thus answered, but this book, with so many passages
highlighted by my yellow pen, is the text that made me want to
continue to find out.

And if YOU, with a Jewish friend or
workmate, or perhaps reading the daily papers and watching televised
news of the conflict in Israel, would like to understand better, to
maybe offend less, to be more in the picture, read Rabbi Milton
Steinberg's "Basic Judaism"....as a starting point.

Almost certainly you will want to go on and read more!

This is a basic introduction for people who either want an overall review of the basics or for people about whom it can't be assumed they know even the basics, like me. Rabbi Steinberg's best quality is his ability to break down and pick apart the basics and his ability to write with extraordinary conciseness. I never felt he was talking down to me, but his handle of English for explaining the complex theological and philosophical concepts was truly remarkable. He also makes a point of drawing out the differences among Jews about Judaism, frequently contrasting "traditionalists" with "modernists". I can't imagine I could have chosen a better book for getting the concept of Judaism. There probably are better books to get, though, if you are looking for a book about how to live as a Jew. The book is obviously very pro-Jewish and he seems usually to give the modernists the better slant without being disrespectful to tradition. If you just want to know what Judaism is, I can definitely recommend this book.

There are two things one should know about this book. One, (as the author points out) this book "is a book about the Jewish religion - not about Jews or Jewish problems, or Jewish culture, or Zionism, but about those beliefs, ideals, and practices which make up the historic Jewish faith." Two, it is indeed - very - basic. Perhaps my thirst for detail keeps me from appreciating this short a summary. I found MUCH more information in three hours on the Internet than turns up here.... Perhaps the book suffers because the author is trying to span the breadth of Judaism, from Reform to Orthodox, in one volume.... On a positive note, Rabbi Steinberg does not beat about the bush - to give one example. he straightforwardly describes the differences between (the various forms of) Christianity and Judaism. His views on St. Paul are "challenging". Christians may not like his judgments, but I thought many of them seem quite on-target. On the negative side, do not expect from this volume a listing of the 613 Jewish commandments (though they are mentioned). Do not expect any description of the Jewish lunar calendar, or any listing of the months. Do not expect any description of the Hebrew language. Do not expect any detailed description of the liturgy of the Shabbat service. I could forgive much of this (since the book is only 172 pages long) except for the fact the author is verbose - especially in the first half of the book. (Incidentally, be aware that "Basic Judaism" lacks all of the following: a bibliography, a glossary, any appendices, and an index!) Though I found this a pleasant read, I wouldn't use it as a starting point for any in-depth study of Judaism.

For those looking for an in-depth analysis of one of the world's oldest religions, you're in the wrong place. But for anyone looking to gain a basic understanding of the tenets of Judaism would be unlikely to do better than this work.

Rabbi Steinberg lays out who the Jews are, what Judaism is, and some of the various interpretations of the faith using clear, concise language and a well-laid out chapter structure that walks the reader through the history and conceptions of Judaism as it has grown over the centuries. Although the book does not go into great depth in any one topic, the scope of the book gives the reader a fascinating perspective on an often misunderstood religion.

A reader who knows little of Judaism may or may not finish this book with a new respect for Judaism, but it will certainly ensure that the reader leaves it with a much greater understanding of it. Required reading for any hoping to gain some understanding of a the great religion that begat Christianity and Islam.

The thoughts and feelings of the Jewish people are nearly impossible to catagorize. This book, however, goes halfway and encompasses all of Jewish religion. Though it is basic (as the title suggests), it is thorough enough to prime one for going into other Jewish studies. It is still simple enough that it has time to explain differences between Orthodox, Conservatives etc. on some issues. It perfectly completes the title "Basic Judaism."

Steinberg addresses all of my concerns and confusion, one by one, and I am grateful. I was confused about what We actually believe and aspire to, and I now know that my birth religion is all that and a bag of chips, thanks to this short, well-written work.

This book is one of the classic summaries of Jewish theology and the Jewish religion. It has a wealth of information, particularly considering its size, and is one of the best ways to learn more about Judaism. It is easy to read, clear and concise, and is easily accessible and valuable to anyone, no matter how much they may already know about Judaism. While some other books may have more detailed information, they sometimes tend to obscure the important points with all the minutiae. This one, even for someone who already knows much of the information in it, is provocative and provides food for thought, and for anyone looking for a review of Judaism, rather than an in depth study, this book is vastly superior to many others.

Steinberg's small volume is one of the best introductions to Judaism ever written. It has a philosophical bent, but also explains traditional and modern Judaism in a way which is easy for the layperson to understand. Though it was written decades ago, it is as fresh today as it was on the day it was first published

I found in Milton Steinberg what I had yet to find in any other 'Basic Judaism' type book. He presents such a variety of subjects in a very clear and concise manner answering the reader's questions even before they are posed. Highly recommended.

This book was recommeded to me as a great place to begin my study of Judaism. The late Rabbi Steinberg very adeptly explains the guiding tenets of this great religion. I found section IV on G-d, to be particularly enjoyable. Anyone beginning a study of Judaism should read this book first.