Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
not the batman I enjoy, June 8, 2004
This review is from: Batman: Absolution (Paperback)
Maybe it's just the more recent Batman comics, but it seems like any Batman volume I pick up is depressing. This book is especially dark and depressing. I can handle a dark, brooding, crime-fighting Batman, but the Batman in this volume is just obsessed to the point of danger. He refuses to see anything but his own point of view. He won't even consider another point of view, because he believes that his view of the world is less biased than anyone else's. He is not an enjoyable character. In this book, he is hunting a woman who, as part of a protest against Wayne Enterprises, set off a bomb several years before that killed a lot of people. Batman turns hunting her into his own crusade, partially because of the deaths and partially because, it seems, his ego is continually hurt by the fact that she eludes him for so long. The artwork looks lovely, but I just can't like the story. I haven't read a lot of Batman comics, but this doesn't seem like a prime example of them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Nice Artwork Can't Redeem This Story, March 22, 2003
Sometimes the problem with graphic novels is that writers tend to put a mythos that is contradicted to some extent in other stories, thus breaking a continuity in the Batman mythos. This is an example of such an outcome for if one was to compare this story to the graphic novel "The Chalice", two very different Batmen emerge.
I am going to avoid recapping the story, because it is so thin and easily discernable, that any hint would leave a possible reader disinterested from the beginning. After all, some other readers may like this slow moving, illogical story.
The major problems in this book are that Batman is a little slow on the up-take in trying to catch a killer who killed some of his employees ten years before. Obvious clues (what little the authors developed) are seemly dismissed. Further, the idea of logic is mentioned several times, just so many illogical conclusions are drawn. Though I think the writers were trying to develop an existential search in Batman, they largely failed. The tension just isn't there.
The last great Batman graphic novels (not counting re-prints such as Dark Victory, etc) are from the period (1986-1992) which produced such great work as , "Year One", The Dark Knight Returns", "The Killing Joke", "Night Cries", "The Birth of the Demon", "Arkum Asylum", and "Digital Justice.", etc. Since that time, the monthly magazines have produced the biggest "hits" and some of their reprints have been re-introduced into prestige hardbound formats.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Unexpected, December 22, 2003
This review is from: Batman: Absolution (Paperback)
One would think that a great author like Jean Marc Dematteis would write a reasonable Batman story. It was a surprise that the end result was not something to be proud of. Dematteis has been a long standing author of Spider-Man and in his prime wrote the thought provoking storylines that slowly careened more to the psychological. You would think that this work right for a character like Batman. Surprisingly, it doesn't. The story picks up with a hellbent, vengeful Batman searching for the bomber of a Wayne Enterprises building that killed many people. It takes Batman 10 years to get to the killer, but of course, you know he ends up there. One surprise is that Batman throughout his years never showcased a vengeful feel to his personality that would fuel his rage for such long a time. The story here falls to being more incredulous in that sense. The other part is that when he does finally reach up to his prey, he is so relentless that he does not believe in redemption and he is intent on making the bomber pay for what she did, though throughout her life that person has completely changed and has become a nun healping thousands in an impoverished land. Simply, said, this is not Batman. You wonder what Dematteis had in mind while scribing this down, but it's a pity that his theme and the Batman character didn't work. I believe that if given the chance, another story by him would give us a better tale. I don't know if that's going to happen in the near future though.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|