5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good, Old-Fashioned, Two-fisted Adventuring, April 1, 2006
This review is from: Batman Archives, Vol. 5 (DC Archive Editions) (Hardcover)
As World War II came to an end, the creators of Batman continued to tell entertaining stories. Actually, those two events weren't really related. Batman and Robin were not a place to find too much in New Deal social relevance, like Superman, nor was it a place for super-heroes to smack around Axis types. It was simply good, old-fashioned, two-fisted adventuring over the course of "Detective Comics" nos. 103-119.
Which isn't to say that Batman didn't have a conscience. In "Coaltown, U.S.A.", Batman and Robin help a coal mining town deal with the mine's cruel and greedy owner. It's a bit heavy handed, but makes its point fairly well. But it also makes one realize that perhaps Batman wasn't so well-suited to such stories.
On the other hand, the three Joker stories are just about pitch perfect, as the Joker at this point was far more interested in building an audacious reputation than in actual mayhem. He usually patterned his crimes around games, puzzles, and clues. Naturally, after being a few steps behind for most of the story, Batman and Robin triumph in the final reel, and send the Joker off to jail.
It also fascinating to see how much science fiction was grafted onto Batman this early on. To the modern reader, used to Batman as a relatively down-to-earth character, the notion of Batman and Robin time-traveling via hypnosis to pal around with Robin Hood will seem incredibly strange. On the other hand, Batman battling it out with a ghost in a library will perfectly consistant.
Given that the archives are quickly approaching 1948, the generally accepted end date of the golden age of super-hero comics, I wonder if DC will be calling it a day, or will they keep going into the fifties, when the sci-fi elements took over completely, and the remaining darkness vanished until the late sixties. I'll probably still get them regardless.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No