Customer Reviews

Batman: No Man's Land, Vol. 2

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

For those who don't know, the No Man's Land titles are the adventures of Batman and his sidekicks in a Gotham City so devastated by an earthquake that it has been declared a federal disaster area. Among other things, this storyline introduced the new Batgirl and Harley Quinn into comic book continuity. This particular volume has Batman newly returned to the city and fighting several of his deadliest foes, including the Penguin, Black Mask, and Two Face. One of the most interesting stories is one in which Detective Montoya of the GCPD (now reduced to the level of a street gang) takes a day off and visits her family, only to find Two Face helping rebuild the community. In a story defying probability, his coin keeps landing good side up, causing Two Face to be ruled by the good side of his personality. There's some other good stuff in here as well, but there's definitely better Batman material available.

(Note: This is a review for No Man's Land Vol. 2. Amazon groups all five volumes and the novelization as one product.)

In No Man's Land Vol. 2, Batman starts to retake Gotham piece by piece. He establishes a line of information with the Penguin. With the help of Batgirl, False Face and other criminals are put away in Blackgate prison, which is being controlled by Lock-Up. Gordon also claims more territory for the GCPD Blue Boys, but at a terrible price, for which the consequences will be paid in future volumes. There are also stand alone stories chronicling the life and trials in NML of its various citizens.

My biggest disappointment with this volume is the artwork. Many varying styles of artwork are featured here (as opposed to volume one, which featured only two), and two of them are too cartoony for the dark, gritty feel NML is trying to achieve. I won't say it's bad artwork, but it definitely belongs elsewhere, like in the Batman animated titles. Thankfully, the artwork doesn't detract from the story, which is still excellent. A couple of continuity issues could be raised (like how Two-Face suddenly winds up in Renee Montoya's community when he has his territory to control), but it's a minor quibble.

After two volumes, NML is still going strong.

Three and a half stars.

Back in 1999, DC Comics came out with BATMAN: NO MAN'S LAND, a momentous year-long event which ran thru the Batman-related titles, including that of Nightwing and Robin (although, unfortunately, none of their issues were collected in the five No Man's Land trades). In the wake of the filovirus and the earthquake which ravaged Gotham and its denizens, Congress shockingly withholds federal aid and declares the ruined city unsalvageable. Gotham is evacuated and then cut off from the rest of the world. With Batman nowhere in sight, what's left of Gotham rapidly devolves into a savage, near feudal state, with city blocks carved up into fiefdoms by vicious gangs and Arkham Asylum escapees. This is the worst Gotham has ever been.

One hundred days later, Batman finally shows up.

Okay, this stuff happened almost a decade ago, but, what the heck - minor SPOILERS follow now.

BATMAN: NO MAN'S LAND, Vol. 2 continues Batman's attempts to reclaim the city from the lawless, except that in this volume he suffers a setback. In Volume 1, he'd already drawn the help of Oracle and the Huntress; here, he forms temporary alliances with the Penguin, who ramrods Gotham's largest black market, and Lock-Up, who now controls Blackgate Prison, which Batman uses to hold captured criminals.

On the GCPD end of things, the GCPD Blue Boys (ex-cops who volunteered to stay in Gotham to uphold law & order) attempt to expand their territory by crossing into the Penguin's border. Ex-Commissioner James Gordon strives to hang on to his principles, even as he feels control of his men eroding away. These issues continue to explore Gordon's bitter disenchantment with Batman, who he feels had abandoned Gotham in its direst need. The two-part "Mosaic" pits Batman against Black Mask and has Barbara Gordon finally finding out about the new Batgirl. "Shades of Grey" has Batman questioning himself, so distracted is he that he puts his costume on backwards.

Also several stand alone stories here, including a story taking place just prior to No Man's Land, an account of an encounter between Detective Renee Montoya and Two-Face. This is significant because it sets the stage for a sub-plot later down the line, as Two-Face would fall in love with Montoya and act on it, but in his own special, deranged fashion. Volume 2 closes with the two-part "Claim Jumping," in which Two-Face finally makes his big move. Come to think of it, everyone makes their big move (Batman doesn't come off too well).

How tricky must it have been, juggling several Bat titles and having to keep tabs on the various storylines. The writers, the excellent Greg Rucka among them, do a good job of keeping things consistent and chronological. The beef is with the artwork, as a dizzying host of illustrators parade in and out. The most grating is D'Israeli, who handles the art chore for the "Bread and Circuses" two-parter. Dude's style is cartoony and is so NOT tailored to the grim goings-on in No Man's Land. The best artist in the bunch is Frank Teran ("Mosaic"), whose gritty, shadowy take is spot on. I also dig his wiry muscular Batman.

For those who care, BATMAN: NO MAN'S LAND Vol. 2 collects BATMAN: LEGENDS OF THE DARK KNIGHT #117 & 119, BATMAN: SHADOW OF THE BAT #85-87, BATMAN #565, DETECTIVE COMICS #732-733, and BATMAN CHRONICLES #16.

If you simply don't have the time to read all five trades compiling No Man's Land or if you just want to read an exciting, well-written book, check out Greg Rucka's novelization of Batman: No Man's Land. I happen to think it's the best book adaptation from a comic book story ever.

A great volume 2. But I must say that in some of the "chapters" I guess you would call them some of the art work is very cartoony-ish, I guess you could say. But then some of the art is very dark and gothic. The way most of us like it. The plot is very interesting and keeps you reading. I am still waiting for volume 3 and am hoping it is as good.

The premise of this series of graphics comic books is the product of genius. A massive earthquake struck Gotham City, so completely destroying it that the federal government declares it a wasteland and orders it evacuated and then sealed off from the rest of the world. Some people refuse to leave their homes, while others choose to stay within the consequential chaos.
The destroyed city has been partitioned into territories held by various groups, some criminal and others with a more noble intent. Police Commissioner Gordon and some of his officers hold one territory, Batman adversaries such as the Penguin and Two-Face hold others and in general other criminal gangs hold the rest. Most of the efforts of all the groups are spent on trying to hold and expand their territories; generally these are border skirmishes with little territory changing hands. Lives are lost on a whim one of the most common forms of entertainment is to have one-on-one gladiatorial style contests to the death. Students of history will recognize the shifting alliances in the battles between princes that led to Machiavelli writing his classic "The Prince."
Batman and the second generation Batgirl have remained in the city and are the ultimate wildcard in the battles for territory. This is the more psychotic version of Batman; he is determined to save the city but is overwhelmed with the task. Commissioner Gordon and Batman are adversaries yet no enemies, although Gordon will seek his help if pressured hard enough.
Post-apocalyptic tales are a staple of literature; this one is unique in that super heroes are involved. There was one mention of Superman flying in supplies, but that is the only time the most obvious solution is mentioned, having the other super heroes come to the rescue. Batman in his psychotic form is an excellent character to be involved in a tale of this type, for his psyche is a consistent battle against an internal apocalypse. This is a great and engaging story, survival in its most brutal form; once I read it I started a search for volume 1.

This is the second volume of the No Man's Land story, where Gotham lies in ruins, cut off from the outside world, battled over by gangs (including the police), and Batman and his team fight for the good of Gotham. It's a gripping storyline.

What exactly does it take to be a hero? Batman proves to you that it is not just bashing head and beating the bad guys. With Gotham City devastated by an earthquake and cut off from the United States, Batman must keep order in a city without and order. Many gangs occupy Gothom vying for supremacy. Even the G.C.P.D. has to fight block by block to keep it's territory. Batman also finds that he has a new ally to assist him in Gotham a new Batgirl. Great reading for one and all.

The story line is captivating and the fact that all of the characters you know and love are brought togther in such new and unique juxtapositions makes this worth recognition.

Seeing Batman being drawn in such a pathetic cartoonish way as shown in the Bread and Circuses part of this series just hurt my eyes. I've seen much much better comic art drawn by an amateur comic artist.

Batman Mosaic is also a pain for my eyes. It might be just me, but I don't like gothic drawing that much, especially when the style is applied to every single characters in the comic.
If your comic style is to read comic with the all the characters having bad teeth gothic style, then this part is for you, otherwise you'll feel the same way I do.

The only reason that I didn't give one star for this part of no man's land is because the later half part of this GN is very well drawn. Especially the ones drawn by Phil Winslade and Mike Deodato.
The story is pretty good, but I really am dissapointed by DC's choice with the first half part of this GN.