3.0 out of 5 stars
Not the story, just the binding quality, March 11, 2009
This review is from: Battle Angel Alita: Rusty Angel (Battle Angel Alita (Graphic Novels) (Adult)) (Library Binding)
To clarify this, I just want to let everyone know this is not about the story, art, etc, just the binding/printing.
The book is the same size as the trade paperbacks are. It is in hardcover, but the pages were trimmed without the actual art being trimmed; which means some of the art gets cut off at the edges. The artwork/words also seem to sink into the middle of the book's spine (the bleed) if they get to close.
As to the cover, the black of Alita's hair is screwy, and the spine of the book is mising the "action" logo at the top, it's just black, while others in the series are not. The cover quality is less crisp that the paperbacks (this becomes a REAL problem with the Last Order series), the colors are less bright and the image less sharp.
This is definitely a collectors item, but is it worth collecting? If you want Alita to last forever (which I do), then sort of. The print quality is great, like the paperbacks, but without the covers being uniform, it's almost pointless to collect them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No