Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Best of the Series (SPOILERS), May 16, 2008
This review is from: Battle Royale Vol. 10 (Paperback)
Following the notorious Lighthouse massacre Shuuya's (one thing I have always wondered is why is it spelt Shuuya in the Manga?) faith is pushed to breaking point as he has to face a terrified Yuko Sasaki and later the insane Mizuho Inada as well as the realisation that he may not be able to save everyone if anyone at all.
In this volume the creators of this Manga made the brilliant move of including a side story that runs along side the events of the here and now showing things from Yuko's parents point of view as they hope that their daughter "wins" The Program but they themselfs know deep down inside that their is no actual winner in The Program and they also realise that the chances of Yuko's survivial are pretty much zero but all they can do is have faith in their Daughter's return and faith that she does right.
Also included in this story is Yuko's troubled history and the revelation that She was traumatised after witnessing a violent fight in School is very effective and adds to the heart breaking tragedy.
Showing Yuko's parents was a brillaint move because it hammers home the point that not only are these childrens lives being destroyed but also the lives of those closest to them and no matter what these childrens actions are in The Program none of them deserved the terrible fate that almost all of them suffered.
Simply put The Program brought out the worst in almost all of them.
Later in the volume Shuuya comes face to face with the insane beyond reasoning Mizuho Inada and though not as strong as the early chapters Shuuya's near breakdown upon realising that saving anyone is an almost impossible task perfectly illustares the near hoplesness of the situation he has found himself in.
Also worth mentioning is Shuuya's "reunion" with Shinji Mimura that shows just how importent Shinji was to Shuuya "I needed him to be okay" is one of the most emotional things said in the entire series.
The final chapters concerning Shuuya's reunion with Noriko Nakagawa and Shogo Kawada along with Mizuho Inada's fate and not as strong as the early chapters (the parts concerning Inada are littered with the annoying fan service that the series is notorious for) but are still very good.
In short V.10 is an emotional ride and the high point of the entire series.
5/5
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not enough Mizuho, January 25, 2008
This review is from: Battle Royale Vol. 10 (Paperback)
This volume successfully wraps up the sad story of the girls in the lighthouse which started in the last volume. Shuuya finds the remains of his friend Mimura as well as his plan to blow up the opressors in the school. And the resident mental patient Mizuho Inada appears, but only briefly. According to the Wikipedia article on her, she was supposed to be a pretty cool messed-up gamer kinda character. You know, the one who went nuts and believed that the game was real. A LARPer to the nth degree. But she just shoots a little bit, listens to the voices in her head, and prances around a bizarre shrine in her underwear before she is killed. I would have liked it if she had more facetime, but this was still a decent volume for the series. Little moves forward, but there is plenty of emotion.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Satisfying Conclusion To the Lighthouse Scene, January 23, 2007
This review is from: Battle Royale Vol. 10 (Paperback)
(Contains spoilers from previous volumes) In the previous volume, we witnessed the lighthouse girls kill each other after Yuko Nakagawa was killed from eating her poisoned soup. The one responsible, Yuko, is actually still alive, and has become very emotionally unstable.
Shuya comes face to face with Yuko, only to be shot at, believing he is a "demon boy". Will Shuya be able to tell Yuko what really happened and save her, or will she have her way and kill him?
The art is fantastic as usual, and there's nothing bad to say about the dailogue. I must say the scenes involving Yuko took much longer than they needed (almost 1/2 of the volume), but the rest of the story was fine.
Definately pick this up, especially if you just read 9, for it's an adequate conclusion to the lighthouse segment. It's getting down to the wire, with only 9 students left at the beginning
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|