Customer Reviews

Bays English Muffins

5 star:		(34)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I grew up in Kansas City, MO, so Wolferman's English muffins were for a long time a staple in my home. I've tried a lot of different muffin brands, from cheap store brands (not worth the money) to higher-end commercial brands. NOTHING beats these Bays muffins!

They're not fork split -- they're actually sliced, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. They still have plenty of "nooks and crannies" for the melted butter due to the high-quality yeast they use. Pop 'em in the toaster, and you'll get a nice crispy exterior and a chewy and flavorful interior. The flavor is wonderful -- just the right amount of yeastiness, but no "sour" taste. Great for breakfast with butter and a little marmalade or jam, but they also hold up well under heartier accompaniments or in sandwiches. The flavor still comes through.

I made room in my refrigerator's freezer for these, even giving up some ice cream room! The sacrifice was worth it.

We went to St. Thomas USVI and this was the only brand of english muffin that was sold in grocery stores. Thinking they would taste just so-so, we were very surprised. Just delicious and unique tasting. There wasn't a sour dough taste to them which most expect from english muffins but when toasted and buttered...they melted in your mouth.

These English muffins were on sale at my local grocery, so I tried them and OH MY GOD, they were so very delicious. Once you have tried these, there is no way you could go back to Thomas's or , heaven forbid, store brand English muffins. They simply don't stack up to the flavor and texture of Bay's English muffins.

I am now ruined for regular English muffins, which is terrible because they are more expensive, but awesome because they are so delicious.

Bay's are so good, it's not fair to compare them to any other brand. They are in a class by themselves. Buying them here by the case is a smart choice if you have the freezer room. They will stay fresh for well over 6 months - not that they will be around that long because you will have eaten them all before then. Plus, even with the shipping cost they are a good deal. No other brand is allowed in my house.

Excellent. Best tasting English Muffin anywhere. Unique and head and shoulders above anything else

I've bought a case of BAY'S before and they last, just like they say. Freeze them, thaw them out and they're just as fresh as when they came through my door. Buy BAY'S - you won't go wrong and you'll never go back to any other brand!

My husband and I grew up in Milwaukee eating Bays English Muffins. We've lived all over the world and have yet to find another English muffin that compares to Bays. They have little pockets that pool with the butter as it melts...fantastic! I'm so happy that we can order them online now.

I discovered Bay's English Muffins when I lived in Cleveland, where they are sold in markets. I now live in Philadelphia and no muffin sold here even comes close to the unique taste of Bay's. The others (Thomas' seems to have a stranglehold on the market here) are just like regular bread that's in the shape of muffins. It's well worth mail-ordering them. Better still would be if Bay's started selling muffins in Philly stores.

I am from Michigan, where I grew up eating Bays English Muffins. I always liked them, but didn't realize how much better they were than the rest. I moved to Seattle and couldn't find Bays ANYWHERE! So, when my mom would visit, she would stuff her suitcase with Bays for me. I tried other brands that looked like Bays, but they didn't come close in taste. Now, my husband and kids love them too, so I order them online!!! They are truly the best!!!

I grew up on Thomas's, have tried other brands including the almighty Wolfermans' (Blech!). My parents moved to North Carolina and found Bays in the local grocery store. At each visit my father would push them and I resisted...should never doubt Dad...they are without doubt the best english muffin I've tried. Can't find them in my area of New York and was so happy to see I could order on-line. I too will make room in my freezer, gladly sacrificing ice cream room!