Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Go with one of the O'Neill collections for a start -, May 26, 2006
This review is from: Mel Bay's Irish Session Tune Book (Sheet music)
If you are a beginner or even somewhere in the limbo of middling, this isn't a collection for you. Yes, the list of tunes is composed of session standards, but having played through everything here I have mostly found myself putting notes besides tune titles to the effect of "better versions elsewhere", and those 'betters' include the standards and standard collections of Captain Francis O'Neill, unadulterated. I am particularly fond of "Gems", and I like the oddity of "Waifs", though not for starters, and there is "Music of Irleand", but not Krassen's take on it...
More recent collections, series, worth considering include Ossian's "Irish Session Tunes" books, the 'David Taylor' collections, "110 Ireland's Best" series, "Mally Presents...100-", the recently revised "Irish Traditional Fiddle Music" by Randy Miller, and another I highly recommend for its variety of tune forms and for beginners or anyone ~ "Matt Cunningham's Dance Music of Ireland". This book I'm slating, the "Irish Session Tune Book", is on my shelf with loads of others, but it isn't one I reach for often or one that I recommend. I find aspects of the notation to be confusing, and as said previously, and you can take it as 'subjective', I'm not fond of the 'versions', preferring O'Neill in every instance...
Your most important tool is your ears, give them as much exercise as you can, listening, and don't be shy to carry a recorder into your local session, after asking if it's alright, practice being a good audience first, to learn their particular 'ways' with the music... But keep that basic respect, consideration and appreciation in tact, it is as much a part of the passion to listen as it is to play, and to be social in the interaction. Don't be shy to ask for help, most of us have a passion for it that includes helping others. We do have a vew grouches amongst us though, myself included. Take advantage of every opportunity you can to learn from others and use these skeletons of the music only as a basic guide. The real joy is in sharing, learning from others and doing it with others. There's the craic... Good luck...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Session tunes, September 14, 2005
This review is from: Mel Bay's Irish Session Tune Book (Sheet music)
This book is clearly notated, easy to read, and has a wide selection of common tunes in jig, slip jig, slide, polka, hornpipe, and reel time. In each tune is provided some limited suggestion as to variation and ornamentation. I play some of these tunes differently, but doesn't everyone?
Books are helpful to have around, and also a fun source for new tunes on rainy days or when practicing. Get a copy of the latest O'Neill's. Ryan's Mammoth Collection is also helpful, the Fiddler's Fakebook another one, the Northern Fiddler if you can find one, etc. There are numerous Scottish collections in a similar vein. There is also a ton of Irish music in abc format on the web, but you can usually find this book at the local music store, since it is published by Mel Bay.
La la la la.. go play some music.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Good, Solid Collection of Irish Fiddle Tunes, April 5, 2011
This review is from: Mel Bay's Irish Session Tune Book (Sheet music)
The other reviewers seem to be taking the review opportunity as a chance to show they are better than the fiddlers who buy this book and use it. Which means they are better than me.
I can accept that. What I have found is that these tunes are good versions of popular tunes. They also feature popular variations in the same tune.
I've enjoyed using the book as a resource to get started on a tune that I heard on an album. Since I read music well, it's just easier and faster than learning by ear.
In the process of picking up a new tune, I will typically change it a bit to suit what I like to do when I play.
Yes, O'Neill's is the bible of fiddle tunes. But many newer tunes are not there.
I strongly recommend this collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|