From School Library Journal
Grade 4-8–Cole has done an exceptional job of showing readers what life was like for children in times past. Using topics such as home, life in an orphanage, sickness and health, work, school, crime, and war, she shows how each one affected young people over the course of American history. For each of these subject areas, she highlights the experiences of one real child, drawing on historical diaries and other documents that give readers an opportunity to learn about life through that individual's own voice. This is a fascinating book, and also a beautiful one. From the brown endpapers to beautifully designed chapter openings, the layout will draw readers into this history of American childhood. The use of sepia as well as black-and-white photographs contributes to a historical feel, and the layout has the look of an old photo album. Sidebars in shades of brown draw the eye to personal accounts and interesting facts, which, together with the many photographs, enrich the main narrative. The list of citations and sources shows the extensive research that has gone into the book, and readers will feel the author's passion for her topic. A rich resource for bringing history alive.
–Jane G. Connor, South Carolina State Library, Columbia Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 6-9. In historical fiction, stories featuring children bring the past alive for young readers. Cole performs the same trick here with historical
nonfiction, presenting a slice of American social history from the particular vantage point of children. Chapters are organized around themes such as family, school, work, and play, and the usual concerns of history books--wars, race and class conflicts, and economic and health crises--are addressed primarily through context. Although the sepia-toned color palette may not instantly grab readers, there is inherent vibrancy in the book's blend of narrative and primary-source quotes and images. Children even younger than the book's target audience will find that the haunting archival photos, such as one memorial portrait of an infant's corpse, speak volumes. Some incautious assertions aside (one passage states that "slaves taught their children to obey unquestioningly any command given to them . . . by loudly ordering them around"), this is a work of impressive density and scope. A bibliography more than 100 titles strong attests to Cole's command of her material. Pair this with Phillip Hoose's
We Were There, Too! (2001).
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved