Brandi Carlile's fourth studio release features one of the most distinctive and compelling female voices in all of music today, together with the voices of her songwriting partners, twins Tim and Phil Hanseroth, who also play guitar and bass. These three have crafted a classic collection of songs inspired by traditional folk and country, but with a rock-and-roll spine. There is much less of the anguish found in Brandi's previous albums and much more affection for family and friends. Perhaps this is because the band is in a very happy place at the moment and because the music was recorded close to home in a relaxed, woodsy setting.
Carlile is renowned for her ability to belt out a tune, wailing like a banshee, "bending notes until they break" as NPR puts it. But there is far more to her sound than this. Her performances are as expressive and as intimate as those of Bonnie Raitt, k.d. lang, or Adele. They get under your skin and stay there. The Twins' smooth, soaring harmonies crown Brandi's husky voice throughout this recording, joined by Brandi and Dave Palmer on keyboards, Jeb Bows on violin and mandolin, Josh Neumann on cello, and Allison Miller and Matt Chamberlain on drums.
"Bear Creek" kicks off with "Hard Way Home," a terrific uptempo country song that makes the most of Carlile's twangy tone. The next tune, "Raise Hell," begins on banjo, but it quickly introduces bluesy guitars to back a raucous lead vocal. The gentle "Save Part of Yourself" follows with mandolins, handclaps, and an irresistable chorus. The lead single, "That Wasn't Me," is an inspiring, gospel-infused tune with Brandi playing piano; she wrote it for a family member struggling with alcoholism. "Keep Your Heart Young" is one of two nostalgic songs on the album, recalling fond childhood memories: grandfathers, wheat pennies, fake CBs, and snowballs.
The upbeat "100" shifts into straight-ahead pop-rock, breaking out of the traditional groove that dominates the first part of the album, but the regretful "A Promise to Keep" returns to folk territory, augmented by a string quartet and sweet harmonies from Tim and Phil. The love song "I'll Still Be There" will seem familiar to Brandi's fans; it bears a strong similarity to many of the powerful songs on her first three albums, as does the next number, "What Did I Ever Come Here For."
"Heart's Content" is a light acoustic love ballad that never ceases to enchant, with string quartet backing and Brandi doubling herself on vocals. The next two tracks, "Rise Again" and "In the Morrow," are among the strongest on "Bear Creek," both melodically and instrumentally, with complex layers that combine to form a magnificent wall of sound. Wrapping up the album is the nostalgic, dreamlike anthem "Just Kids," featuring a looping piano figure, a snare drum, and harmonies that bring to mind the Beach Boys. Sounding very different from anything Brandi has released before, it recalls the days "when bedtime was our biggest fight": "Over the rainbow, out in the snow / Learning to walk with sand in our toes / Long to be tall, kissed when you fall / Hoping that someone will come when you call."
Check out the brandicarlile website for a variety of videos, including a clip of from an electrifying live show at Austin City Limits in which the band rocks out on a hell-raising version of "Raise Hell." Entertainment Weekly's website has a moving video of "That Wasn't Me" starring the legendary Kris Kristofferson. Both songs, together with "A Promise to Keep," appear on a cozy Tiny Desk concert at NPR. There's also an extended conversation at the Huffington Post between Carlile and radio host/music blogger Mike Ragogna. And if you don't have them already, pick up all of Brandi's previous albums, including last year's awesome CD, "Live at Benaroya Hall with the Seattle Symphony."