Customer Reviews

Beard On Bread

5 star:		(25)
4 star:		(10)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

O.K., the bread produced by your soulless bread machine tastes just fine and you have learned some techniques for disguising it's tell-tale tank shape. But haven't you wondered what it would be like to get you hands in the dough? To change and rearrange things a little for variety every now and then? To smell the yeast as it proofs? To experiment with different flours and additives? To pull dried dough from the hairs on the back of your hand for several hours after a session of bread baking? Let James Beard lead you through the joys of making real bread with you in command--not according to the programmed instruction of some microchip with less RAM than you had on your desktop in 1982. Beard's book is an excellent guide to some great breads. He offers a good basic white bread recipe for your first loaf. It is easy and it makes a single loaf. Thus, you get to learn the art of proofing yeast, kneading, and following basic instructions before you invest in exotic flours, herbs, baking pans, etc. I have especially enjoyed the classic Graham bread and the Maryetta's oatmeal bread recipes. The latter can be easily converted to a raisin bread with a little cinnamon, raisins and granulated sugar rolled into the dough before baking. You can really take these recipes and ad lib a little after you learn what you are doing. And, the Graham bread: third time's a charm. Just remember that the baking time is additive: ten minutes at 425 degrees then another 30 to 35 minutes at 350. It's not clear from his text and my first batch was a little chewier than I would have liked. But, fully cooked, this bread is a show stopper when company comes. You can begin to appreciated bread as the staff of life with hearty breads like this one. Try the great yeast-leavened buckwheat pancakes. They are well worth an investment in some Vermont maple syrup. And don't dare spread margarine on any of Beard's breads. He uses butter liberally in his recipes. He butters his pans. He recommends spreading butter on every finished bread. And, according to the brief bio in the endmatter, it finally killed him when he was 81. Enjoy. Use your bread machine to hold the pages open while you mix your dough.

Beard on Bread is a unique bread cookbook. Written before the food craze began, it was written in part, to help home cooks duplicate the bread that their mothers and grandmothers made. To this end it gets home cooks back in touch with the miracle of yeast, the smell of bread dough and the sheer joy of making bread. Beard begins with what we used to think of as "plain" bread and moves on to a wide range of multigrain breads, sweet breads and breads that are traditionally American.

Though it has drawbacks I love this cookbook, and, over the last thirty years, have made every recipe in it.

What's best about this cookbook, and what makes it irreplacebable is this:

1. Tested recipes with excellent introductions. Beard on Bread was written after James Beard spent hours and hours working with dough and writing down what he thought. The recipes are introduced with his take on each. Some of the recipes come from other cookbooks, and their authorship is attributed. (How refreshing!) Beard tells you when he considers a recipe experimental, and when he is not terribly enthusiastic about the type of bread (sourdough). He also tells you when to go look at a different cookbook. His recipe for french bread is "french style" and tells the reader to consult Julia Child's Mastering the Art of French Cooking, if a more authentic version is desired.

2. Clear instuctions and illustrations. If you begin with the introduction of this book, you will get a very good idea of how to make a basic loaf, and go from there. Kneading is illustrated, and there are illustrations of the loaf pans you will need.

3. A progression of difficulty. Beard begins with recipes he believes are easiest to master and progresses from there. He tells you when dough is going to be sticky and hard to work. He tells you not to give up! And he is right. Some of these recipes are a bear to knead.

So, why not five stars?

The reason this book is not five stars has to do with changes in taste and technique in American cooking.

1. Taste: Beard on Bread was written when most Americans considered bread to be a bland slice of white bread, and "homemade" bread to be a slice of white bread with quite a bit of milk and sugar. His basic white style bread, set out in a very small recipe, won't taste all that great, unless you use a very good flour, preferably KA. His homestyle bread seemed sweet to me. If you want to make an excellent homestyle white bread, I would strongly suggest the Fannie Farmer cookbook, or the one on the bag of King Arthur Flour. Beard also likes his bread sweet. The addition of sugar is necessary everywhere he puts it, but I have found that some breads, such as his pumpernickel recipes are too sweet for savory sandwiches. I cut back, accordingly, on sweeteners.

2. Technique: Beard on Bread preceeded the foodprocessor/dough hook/bread machine revolution. Personnally I would ditch the bread machine, but using a foodprocessor with a kneading blade or a dough hook can do great things for your cooking, and make bread making routine rather than an event. In fact, many recipes are easier and better if you begin the kneading process with the processor, but finish it by hand. The problem with using the food processor is that many of the recipes can only be adapted with trial and error. If you have very heavy duty Cusinart food processor you may be able to do most of these recipes in the machine--but your ingredients must be cold or you will make a terrible mess and overheat the machine. (Beard always calls for warm ingredients.) If you have another food processor you may be able to use warm ingredients, but be careful about overloading. Most of the time I have split large recipes into two kneading batches, but that is not always easy.

As I have used the book I have filled it with notes that have helped my cooking. My two favorite recipes are Cornmeal Bread and Jane Grigson's Walnut Bread.

Cornmeal Bread- If you use a Cusinart, cook the cornmeal early in the day and cool in the frig. Beard says this creates a "well risen" loaf, but I have had to double the yeast to get the usual amount of rising. This means four packets of yeast for the recipe, or two per loaf. The bread is very sweet and some bakers may want to cut back a bit once they have tried the original recipe. My family loves it the way it is written.

Jane Grigson's Walnut Bread-This bread is absolutely delicious. It includes a lot of onion and walnut oil. (Beard says the walnut oil is optional but I would not make the bread without it.) The recipe fails to mention that the loaves will be very brown.

The cheese bread is delicious. The result tastes a lot like cheddar, even if you use the parmesian cheese suggested.

English muffin bread required no kneading and the result is excellent. I did not have good results with the Microwave English Muffin bread, possibly because I have a very small microwave.

Good luck.

`Beard on Bread' is one volume of a series on specific culinary topics by leading American culinary writer, James Beard. While fellow experts who knew him such as James Villas attribute Beard with an encyclopedic knowledge of food, he was not particularly an expert on bread. So, what we get in this book is an excellent selection of recipes covering a wide range of uses and techniques, but without the depth of understanding about breadbaking and its techniques which you get in books from Peter Reinhart, Nancy Silverton, or Rose Levy Beranbaum. This is not necessarily a bad thing. Cookbooks full of relatively simple recipes from a very reliable source for a small list price are always valuable to a wide audience. And, if you are reading this review, the chances are good that this book is more appropriate to your needs than one of the bread books from those leading lights I cited above.

Dedications of books are generally relatively uninteresting, as they are most commonly made to close family members who had a lot to do with the author's surviving the experience of writing the book, but little to do with inspiration on the content of the book. This book's dedication is revealing, in that it is to the great English culinary writer, Elizabeth David, who, in addition to her famous books on the cuisine of France, Italy, and the Mediterranean, was the proud author of a superb book on English breads and baking. I am in the middle of reading that book now, and I am genuinely surprised that the book is not cited more than it is by other authors. It is a large book with really substantial sections on both the technology of bread baking and the history of bread baking in England. If you are familiar with David's book, Beard's book is, in comparison, a minor work whose survival in print rests largely on the reputation of the author and the fact that it does give us lots of good recipes at a low cost.

Beard is well known for having created something of a little book writing shop staffed by disciples who wrote most of the actual text attributed to Beard. The most prominent of these are Barbara Kafka and Marian Cunningham, both of whom are easily charter members in an American cookbook hall of fame for their own work. And, if they are not, they should be. But this book, I suspect, has just a little more of James Beard in it than most published under his name. Biographies of Beard often cite how he constantly experimented with bread recipes, even though this was not his speciality. Oddly enough, if he can be said to have any speciality more specific than American Cuisine, it is probably grilling and outdoors cooking.

The best thing about this book aside from the pedigree of its author is its range of subjects. Without touching on artisinal baking, Beard manages to touch just about everything else the world calls bread. The principle subjects are:

Basic Yeast Bread and other White-Flour Breads
Whole Wheat Breads
Sweetened Breads and Coffee Cakes
Egg Breads
Batter Breads
Baking Powder and Soda Breads
Rolls
Flat Breads
Filled Breads
Fried Cakes
Griddle Breads

The fact that this book was first written in 1973, just before the explosion in food interest in the United States means that much of what is in the book has just a touch of the retro about it. I am happy to find that `instant' yeast had just become available before this book was written and Beard took this opportunity to comment on it. I am especially happy to discover that while Beard recognized that it might be faster than the more familiar `active dry' yeast, he believes its results were simply not as flavorful as the older dried yeast.

My favorite example of a retro recipe is the pancake recipe in the last chapter that leavens these goodies with yeast rather than with buttermilk and baking soda or baking powder. Thus, Beard's Yeast Griddle Cakes no longer qualify as quick breads, since it is advised that the starter be mixed and let to sit overnight. If one wonders why in the world one would want to make pancakes with yeast, you have to remember that yeast was available before commercially prepared baking powder, and, buttermilk or vinegar may not have been as commonly available as the yeast, since yeast was such a good leavener for lots of breads for which chemical leaveners did not work.

To those for whom this is important, this is a very homey book. Lots of recipes are borrowed from friends and acquaintances, only a few, like Jane Grigson, are recognizable culinary writers. Note that many traditional breads such as brioche are not made by a traditional recipe. Virtually every brioche recipe I have ever seen, even in books on `easy cooking' ask for an 8-hour rise, preferable longer, overnight. Beard's recipe does not do this. His brioche recipe can be done in about the time it takes to make a classic white bread loaf. Thus, this is not the book for someone interested in professional bread baking or even an amateur approximation of classic professional recipes. This is a book which is fun to read and a great source of inspiration when you just happen to want to try some old school bread making.

My only caveat is that unlike books from the experts listed above, there is little information to help figure out what may have gone wrong if the recipe does not come out as expected. And, bread baking simply does require just a bit more skill than you average savory dish.

I have quite a few James Beard books. If you like his style, you won't be disappointed with this one-as usual, the instructions on technique and so on are very clearly presented, and the illustrations are attractive. However, you may find some of the recipes overly endowed with fat content (well, this is James Beard after all!) and somewhat biased against some very popular categories of bread, such as sourdough or wholemeal types of breads. For a more comprehensive bread book, I would recommend Bernard Clayton's New Complete Book of Breads over this one; and if you're a real beginner when it comes to hand-kneaded (non-bread machine) bread, you can't beat the bread technique section of Julia Child's The Way to Cook. But it's still a book well worth having on your cookbook shelf, together with its sister book, Beard on Pasta (which I would rate a bit higher than this one.

Breadmaking can be great fun once you know how to do it, but for a novice, it can seem more time and frustration than it's worth. When you're struggling to make that first loaf, James Beard reminds you not to be too hard on yourself. After all, he notes, bread doesn't come out perfect every time, even for the best bakers. Just keep experimenting and you'll eventually get it right.

Beard's reassuring words and sound advice certainly worked for me. I've found his recipes easy-to-follow and the results tasty. Every good food writer has his or her quirks. Other reviewers have commented on Beard's liberal use of butter. I'll warn you that he also has a real affinity for salt (and admits as much in a footnote to his basic white bread recipe). I've noticed that similar recipes in other cookbooks call for half the amount of salt that Beard uses!

In any case, these things are a matter of taste and the recipes are easily adjusted to suit your own. The important thing is that Beard teaches the basics better than anyone.

The late James Beard (1903-1985) - began a high profile career in the culinary community by writing his first major cookbook in 1940, followed by Cook It Outdoors, published in 1942.

With such titles as The Complete Book of Barbecue & Rotisserie Cooking, Fish Cookery, Treasury of Outdoor Cooking, and Casserole Cookbook, James Beard kept his focus on simple recipes with what he called honest ingredients that reflected his American heritage.

Written in 1973, Beard on Bread was Beard's best-selling book in his lifetime. It demonstrates a classic example of Beard's philosophy for simplicity; reflecting the ingredients, and tastes popular at that juncture of our culinary history.

It brought back memories to see my maiden name in my old 1973 copy. Beard on Bread and the Sunset book on bread were our best published instruction during that bread-making revival 35-years ago when bakers relied on packaged yeast as their prevailing leavening agent.

Already a serious cook at the time, Beard on Bread gave me the confidence and skill to bake the bread I needed to bake to keep food on my table as a young struggling artist with my first art gallery opening. The unintended consequence was a waiting list to purchase not my paintings, but my bread!

The recipes may lack the sophistication, taste preferences, and comprehensive instruction demanded by much of today's cooks. Sassafras, for instance still boasts that Beard endorsed their baking products, but one must conclude that the kitchen accessories of 35 years ago were quite different from today's more sophisticated equipment.

Beard was not fond of homemade sourdough and his book's content reflects this predilection. He stated homemade natural leavening agents are "very unreliable" which is not helpful for today's baker aspiring to artisan baking.

His Finnish Flat bread recipe using dry commercial yeast for leaven, attempts to embroider the taste of an authentic European sour rye sponge by way of stale beer and buttermilk.

I am neither a fan of Peter Reinhart's taste in bread recipes, nor his style of writing. Reinhart, still praises Beard on one of my least cherished recipes, Anadama bread. The recipe reflects the preferences in many of Reinhart's recipes for dense, sweet bread recipes with molasses, sugar, cornmeal, butter, packaged yeast and a tablespoon of salt. Reinhart, like James Beard, are attracted to sweet breads, the use of much sugar, fat, and salt in their bread percentages.

For today's baker, I recommend Nancy Silverton's, Breads from the La Brea Bakery : Recipes for the Connoisseur (Hardcover). Or, Bo Friberg's The Professional Pastry Chef: Fundamentals of Baking and Pastry, 4th Edition, or, The Village Baker: Classic Regional Breads from Europe and America by Joe Ortiz.

For those who are really hooked, I recommend, The Bread Builders: Hearth Loaves and Masonry Ovens by Daniel Wing, Alan Scott.

This is my favorite simple bread book. The book I would buy for anyone interested in learning to bake yeast breads. It is filled with classic bread recipes from brioche to whole wheat bread. James Beard was a pioneer in appreciating American cooking. His recipes are clear, easy, informative, and most important in a cookbook, inviting. Highley recommended are the challah, pita, and white bread recipes. If you are yeast phobic, don't worry, he has plenty of non yeast recipes. But, beware,once you open the book, it will be hard to resist trying some of the yeast bread recipes. Bread machine users should note this book was written way before these machines were invented

I bought my first copy of Beard on Bread when I was in college in the early '70s. Lost in my travels I bought another copy in 1983. The covers are now held on by tape and the pages are stuffed with post-its and splattered with batters and egg-washes and god-knows-what else. This book bears every scar of nearly twenty years of regular use. If you are new to breadmaking I don't think you will find a better book to start with. You may eventually move on to books on artisinal baking in woodfired ovens. But I'll bet that you too will find reason to return from time-to-time to Beard on Bread.

This book comes highly recommended, as this is my only bread book. I have not found the need to refer to other books. The collection of recipes and the tips for baking bread have been quite complete. I have tested a lot of the recipes, and most of them have come out excellent.
I have had to warn those who have borrowed this book to reduce the salt. On his own admission, James Beard seems to like his bread salty.
Despite this however, it is a truly comprehensive book. And yes, it does tell you very nicely that each time you bake bread it almost always comes out different. Beard actually encourages you to try his recipes to find them out yourself. I have, and I am happy I have this book!

Never having known a bread machine, this book for many years has provided me with an outlet for stress as good as a good run, wonderful and delicious bread for my family and the sense of accomplishment that comes from a job well done. The technique and recipies are accessible, leaving room for creativity, and the number and variety of bread recipies make this my very favorite bread book.