From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 3?Who'd ever think a bad guy could be beaten by a balloon? Why, Mahy, of course, who teams up with Allen in another book with an outrageous plot and its own wonderful logic. When Sam Appleby asks his father to make him a sword, his gentle father is shocked. Sam tells him that "Mr. Mackie made Hacky Mackie a sword with a red jewel stuck on the handle." Hacky also has a plastic dagger, a slingshot, and a laser gun. Sam's father is unimpressed and buys instead a balloon, a chocolate cake, and a sunflower. Then, when the two boys and their fathers stop at the bank and run into Buckbounder, a notorious bank robber, readers will be delighted to see which of the two families saves the day?and how. A fast-moving story line, funny names, and lots of alliteration make this a great read-aloud choice. Allen's comic pictures, like James Stevenson's, are deceptively simple. The artist shows the obvious (the chocolate cake in the face) and the subtle (both Mackies with their beady little eyes) equally well. His sense of the ridiculous is right in sync with Mahy's. Overall, this book revels in its own silliness, which kids will love. Adults will appreciate the anti-violence message, which is there for those who look for it but it doesn't get in the way of the fun.?Lauralyn Persson, Wilmette Public Library, IL
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 4^-8. With a slapstick tall tale, Mahy has fun with the macho gang and with the peaceniks, and Allen's wild, cartoon-style illustrations extend the farce. Sam Appleby would love to have a sword or a plastic laser space gun to play with, but his bespectacled dad is aghast: "Never! No violent toys in our family." Instead, Dad buys Sam a balloon and a sunflower, and they take home a prickly rose and a chocolate cake for Mom. Bully Hacky Mackie and his dad jeer at the gentle Applebys, until the scoundrel Buckbounder tries to rob the bank. The bullies cower in fear, while Sam bangs his balloon, his dad plasters the robber in the face with chocolate cake, and they jam the sunflower pot over his head. Without saccharine messages, the silliness is all the more effective because Mahy acknowledges that we all get angry and would so long to have just one weapon--well, at least a water pistol.
Hazel Rochman