"Becoming Chaz" is certainly one of higher profile documentary efforts to be released in the last year. Promoted extensively in the media by Oprah Winfrey (its television premiere was on her network) and Rosie O'Donnell, the film tells the personal story of Chastity Bono as she goes through gender reassignment surgery to become a man. It's an intriguing subject handled with candor. Putting a celebrity face on the issue certainly might make the topic more visible to those unaccustomed to such things and, in my mind, a little education and mind expansion is always good! I don't think that I have to say that Chastity (now Chaz) Bono is the offspring of Sonny Bono and Cher and has always been reluctantly in the spotlight. Her trials and tribulations have been documented by the press though the years, and it seems that this documentary was an effort to put this life changing story out to the public on her own terms. In as much, this is a successful exploration of the psychological process that brought her to such a momentous decision.
Shot largely in a home movie style (no glossy production here), most of the film spends time with Chaz and his girlfriend. The two have shared some hardships, but both speak with clarity and honesty when it comes to the upcoming procedures. The movie gets up close with hormone treatments and even documents the time period in which Chaz's chest is altered to be more masculine. The movie is at its strongest when dealing with the specific transitional adjustments--both physically and emotionally for the duo. We also get some reactions and interviews with family and friends. Cher does participate in a limited fashion. While it is clear that she has had some difficulty wrapping her mind around the change, and the two share an openly tumultuous past, she is making adjustments and progress in supporting Chaz's decision.
"Becoming Chaz" is certainly an easy recommendation for those interested in the topic. It is a very strong film when dealing with the specific aspects of the transition. However, it seems somehow less than all-access. The focus on the procedure is so single-minded, some of the personal issues that are hinted at are never really explored. I know that no one wanted the film to be personally invasive or exploitative, but it does raise as many questions as it answers from a biographical standpoint. Outside interviews, especially with Cher, are very cautious. The movie hints at some major challenges to Chaz's relationship with his girlfriend. Only some are explored and those are in direct relationship to the procedure. It all seems very controlled, which is okay, but it's a fine line for a documentary and such decisions should be as seamless and unnoticeable as possible. Still, I credit Chaz for putting a public face on gender transitioning and helping to educate on the phenomenon. Check it out! KGHarris, 8/11