9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great information on attachment in adoption, June 22, 2005
I don't entirely agree with the other reviewer who said that this book is too scary. It *could* be scary, but the author bends over backwards to preface everything by telling you *not* to be scared off & that extreme cases are relatively few. I certainly did not get the impression that he believe that intervention is necessary for attachment. He does a great job of provides tools to assist in healthy attachment from day 1, as well as helping to discover if there are issues to be aware of later on. I am normally one to shy away from "scary" topics, but this book made me feel well-equipped - not scared. Note: I am now editing my review after having read section 3 of the book (the final section). That did get scarier... but this book still provided a lot of insight & helpful advice for promoting attachment.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Abusive Therapy, September 21, 2011
This review is from: Becoming a Family: Promoting Healthy Attachments with Your Adopted Child (Paperback)
The author, Lark Eshleman, is a proponent of "Attachment (Holding) Therapy," its parenting methods, and the unrecognized diagnosis "Attachment Disorder" (a catch-all list of signs that demonizes children). These practices have been denounced by professional organizations as abusive and inappropriate for all children. See "APSAC Task Force Report on Attachment Therapy" in the journal *Child Maltreatment,* Feb 2006)
The author is a fan of Martha Welch, MD, who claimed Holding Therapy could cure autism. On page 49, Eshleman has a parent describe Holding Therapy:
"ABOUT ANNA Anna was taken to a Russian orphanage immediately after she was born...At age four and a half she began intensive attachment therapy....[H]er mother describes some of her experiences with Anna. 'On Wednesday we had our first holding time. Anna wanted a bedtime story and I said we should try doing it a new way, alternating sentences while I held her in my lap. She hated this. She was squirming and yelling and kicking. On Thursday I came downstairs with a power screwdriver and Anna asked if I was going to hurt her. We went straight into holding time.... She squirmed, kicked, and tried to hide her face in my side. I kept kissing her and she kept pushing me away, sometimes so forcefully I though I'd get a black eye or blood nose. She screamed, "Don't kiss me! Got your hands off me! You're hurting me!" I kept telling her to do deep breathing....Holding time lasted forty minutes....A few days later, I came into my room carrying a hammer to hand a picture...Anna asked if I was going to hurt her, and again we went into holding time.'"
Besides coercive restraint as therapy, Eshleman also promotes another abusive practice called "Reparenting," or the forced age regression of children. Children are treated like a baby or toddler against their will -- bottle fed, bathed, dressed, baby talk, etc.
And straight out of the mouth of Nurse Ratched in "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest," Eshleman says teachers should be taught something she calls "Funneling." With this practice, the teacher frames comments to the "Attachment Disordered" child in terms of whether the child's behaviors and accomplishments would meet with his mother's approval.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Good, but deserves a warning before reading!, May 30, 2005
Warning... this book could instill a LOT of fear! Granted, it is an excellent book in describing a healthy attachment and how to achieve this with your adopted child; only that is NOT the book's primary purpose. The author wants to illustrate what is not healthy, and how often these "unhealthy" attachments occur, specifically in international adoptions. The author write this book firmly in the belief that no matter how much love you shower upon your adopted child/children they will always lack the ability to bond unless intervention is taken.
So, if you choose to read this book, it is best to read as a "heads-up." Because, even though this book appears more "doom and gloom," there really are a lot of great suggestions to help build this much needed bond with your adopted (even bio) child/children, and the author also suggests the best types of therapies for these children with RAD (reactive attachment disorder) as they will not respond to "normal" therapies.
Unfortunately, the negative seems to so overpower the positive that if you aren't careful, you may be left re-thinking your adoption all together.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No