7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
In the Army Now, January 19, 2009
This review is from: Beetle Bailey "The First Years: 1950-1952" (Hardcover)
The best book on Beetle Bailey is Mort Walker's Private Scrapbook
Mort Walker'S Private Scrapbook That book is a dazzling, hardback, color extravaganza of all things Beetle and Walkerania (I just made up that word). But among the many revelations in that book we learn that Mort and co. regularly produced a Swedish comic book (as shown from the included pin-up of Miss Buxley). The present book was originally released in Sweden (or possibly another Scandinavian country), and was edited by Alf Thorsjo. If the private scrapbook is five stars, then this book is four. But lets give the Scrapbook an unprecedented six stars, and then this one can get five. Why?
Having read many of the Beetle Bailey collections from Comicana over the years, I was tempted to undervalue this one, as I thought it was merely a European version of already published comics. On closer look, however, it's a bit more than that. Beetle Bailey: The First Years is a coffee table sized, color cover, hardback 280 page collection of all the Beetle strips from September 1950, when the strip first appeared, through 1952. In that it follows the format of the Complete Peanuts, Dennis the Menace, John Stanley comics and other collections happily finding their way presently back into print. What casual Beetle readers may not know however, is that Beetle started out in college, not the Army, and his nickname was Spider, easily changed to Beetle as another comic had first claim on that name.
The Sunday strips are unfortunately not in color in this book, but a five page introduction is. The black and white daily strips are large, printed three to a page on slick, quality paper, the way they ought to be. Beetle doesn't join up until around fifty pages in, and then he's recruited partly on a dare from his college dorm pals, some of whom enlist and some get drafted for the Korean War, and partly by accident. The next two hundred pages or so are a treasure trove of the sort of early Beetle Bailey comics that collectors line-up to buy on E-Bay, with a brief afterword about the milleu of the 'fifties, and a two page spread of unpublished and alternate version strips.
The roster of personnel has changed over the years, along with the style and character design, as with most long-running comics. My view is that the character look gets better and better. The most dramatic change is Sergeant Snorkel, who doesn't gain his well-known rotund look until 1963 (the cover interestingly shows a latter-day incarnation of Beetle and the Sarge).
Anyone having read the Private Scrapbook, and there seen glimpses of these early strips, would doubtless like to read more. Comic fans cracking the cover of the present volume will likely be surprised at the vim and vigor in the early strips, as well as the clean, bold, graphic style and careful artistry. Now that the King Features cartoons are out on DVD, and with more comics being reprinted, it's a great time to discover more of Mort and Walkerania.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thanks for publishing this, May 21, 2010
This review is from: Beetle Bailey "The First Years: 1950-1952" (Hardcover)
An essential book for anyone interested in one of the most popular comic strips of all time
Anyone who wants to know how Beetle Baily started out as a college student to then become an Army private should buy this book.
Wonderful commentary, terrific reproduction of comics.
I only wish they would have continued with 1952 to 1953, instead of 1965.
It is the 1950's strips that are really hard to find.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The most famous fictional soldier of the U.S. Army, August 12, 2010
This review is from: Beetle Bailey "The First Years: 1950-1952" (Hardcover)
A cornucopia archive of graphic humor featuring Mort Walker's private, the most famous fictional soldier of the U.S. Army.
Beginning in Rockview University, Beetle is soon transformed to a soldier among soldiers. More than two years of strips including the Sundays from the time period and a roguish unpublished strip in which beetle's eyes are actually seen in one panel.
The early work is perhaps slower paced and the art less refined than the current production, but I do not miss Beetle being beaten up by Sarge at all.
Includes a brief Mort Walker biography. Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No