10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Makes you think - just as a book should!, July 29, 2006
This review is from: A Beginner's Guide to Reality: Exploring Our Everyday Adventures in Wonderland (Paperback)
Okay, I'll be honest: perhaps the 5 stars are a bit much. This book is not that revolutionary, and it is not brilliant. Nonetheless, I was fascinated and impressed by the way the author is able to bring many strings in thinking about what "reality" is. And the book is utterly readable.
The book circles around two aspects: that reality has a social and a physical aspect. In the first part of the book, Baggott describes the social dimension of thinking about reality; he takes much from Baudrillard and John Searle. (As I said, the book is not original, except in its bringing together different strands of ideas.) In the second part, Baggott describes how philosophers from the ancient Greeks until the present day have thought about what constitutes reality and how we are able to know it. Here the author describes the ideas of Plato, Descartes, Putnam and Nozick. In the third part, Baggott describes the physics of reality, especially quantum mechanics.
I liked the first and second parts. If you're not a philosopher, these two parts can be considered as introductions into philosophy (or rather metaphysics). Baggott describes philosophical ideas in simple terms and uses concrete examples to make his point. The third part for me was the most boring. Baggott tries to describe the weirdness of the quantum level. He may do a good job in describing quantum mechanics, but there are books and movies (e.g. What the Bleep Do We Know?) on the subject that do a better job.
The conclusion of the book is simply and to some may be disappointing: after having deconstructed the view that reality is independent, logically coherent and that science comes ever closer to the truth about reality, Baggott believes that although there is no justification for this position, scientific realism "is justiried because it is the most natural position - the default assumption - of most working scientists." (239) Yet, scientific realism can only be accepted as an "act of faith". Baggott may be right here (as I think he is), but to many this may not be satisfactory.
I read this book in my vacation, and was thoroughly fascinated by it - despite the critical things I said before. Being a huge fan of the Matrix, this book goes into the philosophy underneath the movies and asks the question, Could it be that we are living in the Matrix? I believe it is possible that we are living in a Matrix, although there is a good chance we will never be able to know it, and this book confirms that conclusion using philosophical arguments. The book is easily readable, but I have read it as a prologue to further study in a truly fascinating subject. This book did what it was supposed to do, it made me think about the unthinkable...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Alice in Wonderland or breaking down the 3 perspectives, July 31, 2006
This review is from: A Beginner's Guide to Reality: Exploring Our Everyday Adventures in Wonderland (Paperback)
The book provides a lot of knowledge from a lot of sources about reality, and remains objective through out. I think if one thing that is great about this book, is the authors ability to remain objective even though in the end he admits to favor 1 of the 3 perspectives that he provides near the end of the book.
The beginning parts should be easy to understand, a little bit of the philosphy was repetitive to the point where I got lost in what he was trying to say or trying to connect, but pushing through and ignoring those bits didn't hurt the rest.
The physics parts when it came to quantum theory were rather tough, and even got into a little bit of math that seemed weird to me, the percentages of directions for example. But again pushing past the points he was trying to make there, didn't hurt much either, you could just take the provided conclusions and move on with out hurting your brain.
Though I don't think you should skip the rest of the book and go straight to the end of it because there is a lot of value in the whole of the book, the epilogue is one of my favorite parts. It is where he takes most of the knowledge of the book and breaks down the 3 perspectives: empiricism, social constructivism, and scientific realism. These can be said to be similar to being Atheist, Agnostic, and Theist.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fun book!, August 6, 2007
This review is from: A Beginner's Guide to Reality: Exploring Our Everyday Adventures in Wonderland (Paperback)
The bottom line for me with this book was that it was just a great read, really alot of fun. I have always enjoyed science and philosophy, and Baggott mixes them both in a way that is interesting, thought provoking, and humorous. I liked the fact that at the end of the book he doesn't insist that you see reality in the way he does, you must decide that on your own. Very well written I thought.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
