Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Read it in one sitting...IF you dare!, December 1, 2001
This review is from: Being Dead (Hardcover)
Vivian Vande Velde writes with such a sure grasp of teen dialogue, teen humor and teen life one is convinced that she must be a perpetual teenager herself.
The seven stories in this volume are by turns spine-chilling, rib-tickling and heart tugging. Some of them all at once.
Each story gives us a protagonist with a haunting problem, a sense of grim humor and (with the exception of the sweet but predictable "October Chill") a surprising resolution.
Included here is a tale of near perfection...thrills, chills, mystery and even a little comedy..."Drop by Drop" will make you laugh even while it's scaring you out of a year's growth. The protagonist, Brenda, struggles to make friends in a new town--and to wonder WHY she, of her entire family, is haunted by the spirit of an angry little girl. Brenda is so funny about her misery, and so typical of the parentally put-upon teenager that we can't help but be sympathetic to her problem. But as the story (it's a long one--64 pages that fly by) unfolds, clues and ominous hints to the nature of the vicious little ghost are also revealed...and they spell disaster for Brenda. In fact, this story is not terrifying because of the ghost but because of the disaster her revelation will mean for Brenda and her family. I
sat in breathless wonder when I finished this tale. It is the best of a wonderful lot and should be read to all teens of a certain age....
Of the other tales, "Dancing With Marjorie's Ghost" is a great
tale for campfire tellings...the final lines will chill you, "For Love of Him" offers a darker view of romance beyond the grave and "Shadow Brother" will disturb anyone who has an older brother and a father who just don't get along. "The Ghost" is
a short, funny piece that certainly owes much to a certain popular film of a few seasons ago. The title story features one of the wildest ways to die and humorously examines the lengths one will go to to provide for one's family.
In all, a delightfully chilly bit of mist and mirrors, perfect for the young reader who loves ghost stories and wants something fresh, thoughtful and funny.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining Way to Pass an Evening, March 24, 2010
THREE QUICK POINTS
*Point 1: The cover is creepier than the stories.
*Point 2: The book is a mixed bag. Some stories are little more than incomplete thoughts while others are quite moving.
*Point 3: The prose is smooth and it makes for easy reading.
STORY BREAKDOWN
Being Dead is a collection of seven short stories: Drop by Drop, about a teenager and her family moving to a new home; Dancing with Marjorie's Ghost, about a man being visited by his late wife; Shadow Brother, about a father's spiral into madness; Ghost Story, about collegians moving into a haunted house; For Love of Him, about a young boy entranced by gravestones; October Chill, a romance between a terminally ill girl and a colonial soldier; and Being Dead, about the experience of a young depression era boy and his family.
MY THOUGHTS
This book was a mixed bag of stories. A couple of them amounted to no more than incomplete thoughts with unrealized potential. Shadow Brother and For Love of Him fall into this category. A few were simply mediocre, or rehashed versions of older ghost stories. Drop by Drop, Dancing with Marjorie's Ghost, and Ghost Story fall into this category. I will say, however, that these three stories were entertaining and what relegated Drop by Drop to this group was its ending, which was trite. But a couple were truly works of art. October Chill and Being Dead, the two final stories in the book, fall into this category. In fact, these two stories alone bumped this review from three stars to four. Both of them left me with a desire to read more, but I didn't feel as though I didn't know enough and both managed to tug at my heartstrings. With Being Dead, my favorite of the bunch, I felt myself gasping at times and laughing at others; there's also a fun twist. (I won't mention it because it would spoil the story.)
Overall, this is a great book to pass some time with. There's nothing overtly frightening about it, but a few stories may give you a goose bump or two, especially younger readers. The gore and explicit situations are also kept to a minimum so I wouldn't have a problem recommending it to younger readers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wide Spectrum of Ghost Stories, September 1, 2009
(3.5 Stars)
Being Dead is a collection of seven ghost stories which range from creepy to funny to poignant, but I should also warn you that you won't find too much to keep you awake with fright between its covers. (It doesn't mean it's a bad book, though.)
Drop by Drop tells the tale of a teenage girl, moving to a rural area with her family, who becomes haunted by a young girl. There was one section in the story which made me gasp because, despite knowing I should have, I didn't see it coming. The first three-quarters of the story was a great lead-in for the climax, but that's where it died. The ending was predictable if not the twist; there's an important lesson in there that I daresay seems disjointed.
Dancing With Marjorie's Ghost is a cautionary tale that reads like something familiar (woman comes back from grave at the request of her "grieving" husband). It's main tenet is to be careful what you wish for (and watch out for karma). Despite its seeming familiarity, it was a simple, quick, and fun read.
Shadow Brother is the story of a family torn apart when the eldest son, Kevin, is drafted for the Vietnam war and dies in battle. Stricken with grief and guilt, his father spirals downhill. A ghost is alluded to, but at the end, it's still a question. Unfortunately, this story fell apart for me partly because of the characterization--they didn't seem entirely believable, especially the relationship between Sarah, Kevin's younger sister and the story's narrator, and her cousin Dwight--and because it seemed more like a patchwork story than a well-flowing one.
Ghost Story is rather straightforward: Collegians start moving into a haunted house, then quickly move out. That's the entire story and it was a super-quick read to boot, but it had me chuckling by the end.
For Love of Him had plenty of unrealized potential. It's about a young man who becomes captivated by the historical gravestones of a man and woman who wouldn't have been much older than him when they died. His obsession soon takes a near deadly turn until the intervention of a mysterious almost-stranger. I wanted to love it--the atmosphere and backstory left plenty of room for growth, but it was vague in all the wrong places and it resulted in a highly predictable ending.
October Chill looks through the eyes of a young girl dying from a brain tumor who meets the ghost of a colonial soldier while working in a recreated colonial village and falls in love. By the end of the story I was wishing it were a full-length novel because I was intrigued by the young man's story and wanted to see more development between them; it all happened and ended too quickly although the story was certainly enjoyable. More heart-tugging than scary with a bittersweet ending.
Being Dead, the book's namesake, transpires during the great depression. A paperboy who meets with a fine piece of luck moments before his untimely death must find a way to deliver an important message to his mother and sister. The voice of the story is vastly different from the previous stories and may throw the reader off-kilter for a moment, but one can quickly acclimate. The story is smooth, poignant, and hilarious--I won't mention *how* the paperboy dies, but I will say I should have, but didn't, see it coming. The events following his death were enough to build the frustration and by the end of the story, when the final message is delivered, I was misty-eyed. By far the most well-balanced and well-written story in the bunch.
Despite not loving two of the stories and finding another two somewhat inchoate, the remaining stories (Ghost Story, October Chill, and Being Dead) certainly made the book a worthwhile read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|