5 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
If true, Islam has veered way off the path, October 3, 2006
This review is from: The Beliefnet Guide to Islam (Beliefnet Guides) (Paperback)
This book offers a defense of Islam against prevalent Western characterizations. Such a defense is needed but this book rings hollow because the authors can see no wrong in Islam. They also make many historical comments that are weak. For example, they imply that Spain was far more advanced than the rest of Europe during the Middle Ages BECAUSE it was Islamic. Maybe. Correlation does not prove causation. The say any serious historian would have to admit the civilizing effect Islam had. Islam in the middle ages was spread by the sword. When the sword wasn't used it was because news had spread that if you don't surrender, you die. If you don't become Muslin you will be taxed into slavery. Maybe that's civilizing, I'm not sure.
In the foreward they justify Muslim's outrage at things like the the prisoner abuse by American troops. They neglected to mention the outrage westerners have at videotaped beheadings.
There are several statements that Muslims dislike commercialization. Hmmm. I'm not convince that commercialization is a bad thing. After all, it's been commercialization that has produced all the world's medicines, airplanes, ships, etc. BTW, the Islamic world has no problem exploiting those byproducts of the evil empire. Especially when it comes to getting oil and the assocaied profits.
Many of the attributes of Islam described in this book are beautiful concepts. The book is directed at westerners. However, I think members of Hamas, Hezbolla, and Al Queda should read the book to remind them of the peaceful nature of Islam.
The authors downplay the militaristic characteristics if Islam. They go to lengths to defend Mohammed's military acts, some of which would qualify as war crimes today.
Other religions also have issues, I'm not trying to single out Islam. I suspect a book on Christianity by a Christian would have a trouble being objective, too.
All said, there are better sources to learn about Islam. However, this one is a quick read if you can stomach the author's attempt to convert you.
Given the hypersensitivity to criticism exhibited by Muslim's today, this review may get me killed. That's why I claim Islam has veered far awy from what these authors claim Islam is.
On the positive side, these authors do try to address many of the western criticisms of Islam. The cite verses from the Koran or Hadith to explain their position. I only wish the Islamic world viewed Islam the way these authors do. I sense they do not based of the constant stream of news I hear and see and read.
I hope Muslims are trying as hard as I am to understand the West as I am in trying to understand them. Something tells me that's not the case. I hope I'm wrong.
Many times while reading this book you will be in disbeleif that Islam is one way but the Islamic militants and fanatics are quite the opposite. The authors try to explain that in the last chapter.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No