166 of 174 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Don't Plan On Using The Belkin Wi-Fi Phone On The Road, January 10, 2007
This review is from: Belkin Wi-Fi Phone for Skype with Boingo Hot Spot Manager ( F1PP000GN-SK ) (Personal Computers)
Being someone who uses Skype constantly for both business and personal long distance and PC-to-PC phone calls, I got a Belkin Wi-Fi Phone for Skype as a Christmas gift from a loved one who knows just how nerdy I am when it comes to new gadgets. I love them!
Unfortunately, I can only say that I *like* the new wi-fi phone from Belkin. Appearance-wise, it's terrific with a sleek black case, color screen and attractive key layout. It's a good, comfortable size and feels about like a stylish mobile phone. It comes with a USB cable for charging and software updates, as well as a regular power cord for charging. You can use the phone while it's connected to the charger, which is what I find myself doing a lot.
The sound quality is good and it connected right to my household wi-fi system once I punched in the security code. The controls are easy to access and use. I was quite excited to get going with it and used it for several days without incident.
Then it froze. No matter what I did, the buttons made no difference and the screen stubbornly stuck on 11:38 a.m. and no amount of prodding would break it free. I looked for some sort of reset button like you get with a Palm or other PDA-like device, but there isn't one. I finally decided that the only way to get the baby to reset would be to take out the battery and put it back in.
Thus, my next problem. The battery cover refused to budge. It was as if it had been super-glued shut. I pulled, pushed, yanked but it held firm. I had no other choice than to resort to the proverbial waste of time - support.
Yep, total waste of time. I tracked down Belkin support, filled out the form to inform them of my problem (frozen screen, stuck battery case) and got an answer from some clueless girl telling me I should go into the menu and use the "reset" function. Duh? The SCREEN IS FROZEN, honey! How the heck am I supposed to do that!
So, back to pulling, tugging and yanking on the battery cover. I finally managed to pry one corner up and get enough leverage to get the darned thing open without breaking it. I pulled the battery out, the phone reset and I was up and running again.
My next disappointment came when I stayed at a hotel that offered free wi-fi. I had hoped to use the phone to make some calls, but, alas, the hotel requires you to open their web page in a browser before you can connect to their access. That's all, just open their page in a browser - no inputting codes or anything. Just an open browser.
The Belkin phone has no Internet browser, a terrible oversight for a product that people will want to use at Internet cafes and the like. Not a smart move, Belkin.
Yes, the phone is supported by Boingo, which has hotspots here and there. In my area, my choices are a UPS Store or an RV park. Somehow I can't see myself hanging around those to make phone calls. I'm out of luck at Starbucks, hotels and anywhere without completely open wi-fi access.
Another minor peave is the lack of Skype chat support. My company uses Skype chat a lot during the business day, so I can't plan on using the Belkin Skype phone exclusively for business because there's no chat support. I understand that trying to do chat on that itsy bitsy keyboard is difficult, but people send text messages all the time on cell phones, so there should be support for chat. If nothing else, I'd like to be able to set the phone up to let people know that I don't have Skype chat, try me on AIM or whatever.
Anyway, don't think I'm totally unhappy with the Belkin Wi-Fi-Phone for Skype. I'm not. It's great to carry around the house with me when I'm not on the computer. It just means I have to switch back and forth between it and a Skype-enabled computer quite a bit. I guess my suggestion for those considering one is to say that it's great if you just want a wireless Skype phone for home, have no need for Skype chat and don't plan on trying to use it too many places outside your home network. It's a shame, but it probably won't work for you on the road or in your neighborhood Starbucks.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
37 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
If you like new gadgets, then it's for you, but pay attention to reviews., August 4, 2007
This review is from: Belkin Wi-Fi Phone for Skype with Boingo Hot Spot Manager ( F1PP000GN-SK ) (Personal Computers)
a) It works without a computer, there's no need to transfer contacts, no computer config, no software to install, no usb/network cable or base station required.
b) It's ready to call as long as you have access to either a 802.11b or 802.11g WI-Fi network.
I've read previous reviews (thanks to all) and knew in advance some of the following drawbacks:
ON THE CON Side:
1) Clock is not accurate even when phone it's on. If turned off, it resets back to 01/01/2000. You need to set time AND date every time.
2) If you "rush" the phone by clicking fast it will lock and reboot itself and date/time resets again. No syncing with an internet clock server.
3) NEEDS a Firmware Update. Tried Menu, Settings, General, Software Updates option and still got the message "You already have the latest software installed". It's: v1.1.0.10 R20 from 2006/12/13 (I've checked www.belkin.com and still there's no update).
4) It should save more than one Skype account (it already saves several Wi-Fi networks & passwords). Logging another user is SLOW and painful.
5) HARD keys. Specially the right "soft key" and the End/Power key.
6) It "rings" a little low, even at max volume. If it's not in the same room, you may not hear incoming calls. Also it only has 3 ringtones and SILENT. There's no way to add more.
7) No belt/holster clip. Hopefully, keypad can be locked/unlocked by holding both the left soft key AND the [a/A*] key. If you want to "roam" with this phone on your belt, then look for a case or swivel case that fits because it's not as small as most modern cell phones are.
8) It doesn't work with most Hot-Spots (at least if they're not "Boingo Mobile"). If you need a browser to enter an user and a password as most Hotels do, you're in the dark.
9) NO Speaker mode.
10) Phone and battery get a little hot when doing long calls (Enough to feel the heat on your ear and hand).
11) The design looks a little OLD and CHEAP. Put it next to a cell phone and you'll see what I mean.
12) No cradle. It comes with one USB cable and a charger. There's no craddle available yet. SMC offers TWO diffent craddles for it's Wi-Fi phone. One it's a charger (SMC Wi-Fi Phone Cradle Charger - Phone charging stand) and another also comes with an access point: "WI-FI PHONE CRADLE CHARGER W/ BUILT IN AP (SMCDPCR-AP)".
13) Skype user logged in the phone appears to be "reconnecting" from time to time. Also it doesn't apper On Line inmediatly.
14) No way to send SMS messages from the Phone.
15) When calling, batteries don't last the 3 hours advertised. I agree it needs a longer lasting battery (maybe a 1500mAh or 1800mAh?).
16) Lots of errors on User Manual. By example, "Keypad tones--Set this as either "On" or "Off"" option detailed on page 44 is completly MISSING on software's phone. Keypad DO NOT HAVE sound and there's NO WAY to turn it "On" or "Off".
Another discovery was that the "SMC WiFi Skype Internet Phone" (SMCWSKP100) is the very SAME device. "Netgear SPH101 Skype Wi-Fi Phone" looks suspiciusly similar to Belkin's. "Linksys WIP320 Linksys Wireless-G Skype iPhone" also has the same look and software screens. I believe that's because all of them are developments of Trolltech.com (navigate to Menu, Settings, Information). Visit www.trolltech.com and take a look at the "Qtopia Greenphone", it has a camera!.
ON THE PRO SIDE: Why I bought Belkin?, because (along with SMC) it seemed to me, the least worst reviewed of all Wi-Fi Skype Phones I've checked (and I liked black, the rest are white ;-). I'm not returning it now because IT DOES what I wanted: Let me do Skype calls whereaver there's a Wi-Fi available (remember: no hot-spots). If network is fast, you'll get very good, FREE (Skype) or VERY CHEAP (SkypeIn-SkypeOut) calls. Voice is VERY clear, with almost no echo, very little delay ("sound latency") on most international calls. That's still VoIP technology's nature, and mostly Skype's software fault, the broadband network and/or because of all the telecom operators in between. Also, so far, I haven't lost calls in the middle of a conversation.
WHAT I WANT: I'm waiting for Belkin firmware update. Also, I'm waiting to see if Belkin rolls out SOON a line of accesories. The biggest battery recommended by the manual (NP-60, used for digital cameras/camcorders made by Fujifilm, Pentax, and Panasonic) is only 1050mAh (the original is 1200mAh & User Manual says it's 1100mAh).
MY DECISION: Seems expensive but surely will pay off. More time and calls are needed to enjoy all of it's benefits, to discover more bugs and to understand Phone's behavior in different networks. Take your time to read the rest of this phone and SMC WiFi Skype Internet Phone's reviews. If you love new gadgets AND don't mind finding some or lots of bugs, then give it a try. It makes cheap calls cheaper by not having to keep your computer "on".
BUT, If you don't want a "Beta product" (Amen, "Blue Devil"), or waste time "debugging" a poorly tested device, then wait until similar, more mature products are rolled out on this side of the planet. Maybe I should check again the "Panasonic Wi-fi Phone for Skype". With excellent reviews... hummmm.
Hope you'll find this review as useful as I've found the rest to me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No