Most helpful critical review
50 of 53 people found the following review helpful
Not so good after all-- BEWARE!
on April 1, 2013
I've looked for years for 100% cotton tank tops. All my old ones have holes because I wear them all the time--under other tops when it's cool and as tanks in summer. Recently I was at Nordstrom and the gal said sorry, we only get the stretchy kind these days. Then I found these online. I was skeptical, thinking they'd be too short or poor quality. So what a pleasant surprise to discover these are exactly what I've been looking for! If you want a simple, basic, classic ribbed tank, look no farther! I got navy and deep heather, and both colors are just what I envisioned. I'm going to order more. Who knows, in another year these may have gone the way of the rest of the 100% cotton tanks....
REVISED! I'm back to say I received two additional tank tops, and what a disappointment! I have to lower my rating from 5 to 2. These come from a different supplier, and are shorter and not the same rib. Yuck! No wonder the reviews here were so inconsistent. People are getting different merchandize. What a crap shoot. How do you know what you're going to get? Sorry, but I think this is irresponsible selling.